SpaceX designed Dragon for Mars
parabolicarc.com
parabolicarc.com
On one hand, you've got the fact that a lot of the Dragon is excess weight you don't really need to send to Mars. On the other hand, you've got the savings in R&D if you can just send your robot up in a commodity capsule rather than having to design a landing system from scratch. Oh, and let's not forget the fact that one-off custom-designed landing systems don't have a great record of successful landings on Mars.
Please note the Dragon, once landed on Mars, will stay there. You could mount it on top of a return stack if you had a crane. I wonder what's heavier - a Dragon or a crane that could lift one. The return stack could be deployed before the astronauts arrive and manufacture fuel required for the ascent and rendezvous with the return (or cycler) vehicle while they are on their way to Mars.
I find a Moon landing more interesting. On Mars you can use the atmosphere to brake, but on the Moon you have to fight a lower gravity to land.
[1] This was posted on HN before by joey http://www.universetoday.com/7024/the-mars-landing-approach-...
All progress in space exploration has been made with baby steps. We flew men around the backside of the Moon three times before actually attempting a landing. Apollo 10 took a lunar lander within 40,000 feet of the lunar surface without landing. Whatever problems are going to arise with a Mars base I think it'd be better to solve 'em with a Moon base first. Apart from anything else it's easy to get home from the Moon if you need to evacuate, whereas easy transfers from Mars to Earth only crop up every eighteen months or so.
Oh, and if you're not aware there's already a SpaceX flight to the Moon scheduled for 2013; one of the teams for the Lunar X-Prize (Astrobotic Technology) has booked one up.
Wow! That's really cool. What kind of mass can SpaceX put on the lunar surface? Anyone cares to do the math?
http://www.aviationweek.com/aw/generic/story_generic.jsp?cha...
Not sure if that includes the fuel you'll need for a soft landing, though.
For comparison, an Apollo lunar lander was fifteen tons including fuel. I'm guessing a Falcon 9 Heavy could manage that.
As for Mars, you can use the atmosphere to shed some speed. You can't do the same on the Moon, but your speed will be lower, so, it may as well end up being the same.
There's a few ways in which Mars is an easier problem than the Moon, including fewer worries about micrometeorites. As far as fuel goes, though, if you can find a good supply of water on the moon then you can start fuelling your hydrogen-oxygen rockets, no worries.
edit: Others have suggested making rocket fuel out of aluminium oxide if you can't find enough water: http://www.asi.org/adb/06/09/03/02/095/al-o-propellants.html
As far as cracking rocks to make Oxygen, that's such an expensive proposition in capital equipment and energy requirements that it's not on the table in terms of resources that will help bootstrap exploration and colonization or that will sustain a mostly self-sufficient local industry.
I had been looking for a succinct article that explains the physical constraints on a Mars landing (for equipment only, say). It's safe to say nobody knows more about that problem than Rob Manning. The node in the discussion you refer to is:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2479398
As with most threads on this subject, commenters not reading TFA believe that the retro rocket solution is straightforward. TFA explains why it's not.
> (damned if anyone's gonna spend six months to a year
> crammed into a Dragon)
Yep, they got much more space in Mars-500: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MARS-500Update: I found this from April: http://uk.reuters.com/article/2011/04/12/us-spaceexploration...
And honestly I'm not sure if it is, but if I'm going to lose my money in a poor investment it might as well go into making rockets!