What is it about the old design that screams "we have a sub-culture" to you? For me, it's just a clean, simple, fast interface.
are you sure that this isn't mostly true for HN crowd? I have seen more and more people participate in reddit recently.
Having said that, I used Reddit more like a phone book than a social media network, so the redesign is lost on me.
The subculture will move on and find a new place to congregate. But it will forever be pursued by the mainstream. This is Eternal September.