Why were the new emissions targets the "right" ones? Why not make them half again and save even more lives? The answer is that they are numbers pulled out of the ass of some CARB or EPA bureaucrat.
In reality it's impossible to say that "1200 early deaths" were caused by VW emissions. It's statistical smoke and mirrors and doesn't even show up as a blip in the normal variation of total mortality of any given year.
How many early deaths were caused by California's refusal to allow or perform proper forest manangement, resulting in this year's devastating wildfires and the pollution they caused? Sorry for the whataboutism. Deaths are deaths.
Of course not. What changed is that in addition to being wrong, what VW did after the laws were changed was also illegal.
> Why were the new emissions targets the "right" ones? Why not make them half again and save even more lives?
Eventually they will, I hope. Change to a carbon-neutral and clean-air future takes time, and we’re in a transition period right now.
> In reality it's impossible to say that "1200 early deaths" were caused by VW emissions.
I mean sure, 1200 is an estimate based on assumptions you could probably quibble with. We know air pollution kills people and we know VW’s cheating significantly increased air pollution. While acknowledging uncertainty, its still important to reason about how many people VW killed.
> doesn't even show up as a blip in the normal variation of total mortality of any given year.
This argument proves too much, by this reasoning nothing that kills less than 100k people/year is real.
> How many early deaths were caused by California's refusal to allow or perform proper forest manangement?
A lot!! And that’s really bad! But it’s an entirely different problem from this one.
The reason why we talk about it so little is that so many own cars and that it's not popular to say that a carowner kills a freigthenly high fraction of a person each year. Whataboutism will always ensue.
Fixing a misbehaving car manufacturer is easier than fixing decades of forest mismanagement. Once the VW thing is over they can concentrate on that (unfortunately they still don't). The forest fire problems are also unique to California. Car emissions are a problem everywhere.
Regulations happen in the real world, where we face untidy compromises between moral goods like "people should be prosperous" and "people should be healthy". There is no good answer to the question, "What is the right level of pollution," but it's still a question we must answer. And then enforce.