Over the months, their ambition has been cut a lot by regulators. No more basket of currencies, now just US Dollar. At this point I'm not sure there's any benefit to it being on the blockchain either.
Over the months, their ambition has been cut a lot by regulators. No more basket of currencies, now just US Dollar. At this point I'm not sure there's any benefit to it being on the blockchain either.
I don't see how this is a surprise. Facebook basically wanted to take monetary sovereignty away from states and give control to private companies. What did they expect? Especially when right now people are noticing the reach Facebook has into our lives and how irresponsibly they're acting with it. Why would any sane person give Facebook any more control over their lives?
Indeed, that was their most unique feature.
A stablecoin pegged to a basket of fiat (say just USD, CAD, EUR, GBP, JPY, SGD), using traditional crypto tools (burning, pegging) definitely has a place and a bright future ahead.
However, there's no need for facebook - defi may be able to do that with smart contracts over wrapped stablecoins (say USDC for the USD, etc.)
Hell, even USD, EUR, JPY would still be EXTREMELY valuable and useful.
So in that regard I wouldn't immediately dismiss a usage of a blockchain as pointless. Given that PoA chains are usually pretty efficient, there also doesn't seem to be an immediate downside to it.
If you want to argue for an alternative to a chain of blocks you could of course do that, but in my personal experience if you consider all the requirements (multi-party, auditable, etc.) the usual argument of "you could just use a normal centralized database" falls apart and you end up with something that in some form or another resembles a blockchain (or something equally complex), so why not use a blockchain?
For most practical applications a git repo where you have some set of trusted notaries and at least M of N notaries must sign each commit is probably closer to what you want. (Or something that is similar logically but still does not fit the standard definition of blockchain, which again is trustless.)
> git repo where you have some set of trusted notaries and at least M of N notaries
There isn't really much difference between a PoA blockchain and what you describe on a data structure level. The main differences here will be the mode of operation (active node vs. passive repository) and builtin support and optimizations for currency transactions.
If you were really inclined, you could probably implement a optimized git client/server that could achieve that (and I wouldn't be surprised if someone has done that already). What's the point in doing so tough, if you could just as well use an existing implementation of a PoA blockchain?
Secondly, it's definitely not secure in the sense that is advertised. Aside from regular social engineering and old-school hacks to get people's tokens, governments have been successful in tracing transections in investigations. That's how SilkRoad got got, and recently Japan did it as well.
Tracing transactions on the BTC public ledger did not lead to the downfall of the Silk Road.
Is that no longer true? I'm not sure if the website is up to date.
I think It was mostly interesting, because It had a potential of going real mainstream if FB really pushed it to it's millions of users that are not technical in one way or the other.
Technically, there is so many ambitious projects going on in crypto space anyways.