i guess you can argue that it increases the pool of connections, but that's a lower quality (unproved) pool than contacts with established players, no?
i guess you can argue that it increases the pool of connections, but that's a lower quality (unproved) pool than contacts with established players, no?
Probably NOT. The bar has been higher in recent batches and as a result, relatively more established companies make it to the batch, as compared to, say, in 2005 - 2007. This benefits both the companies and YC -- the companies benefit by the excellent environment and networking opportunities, and YC ends up making somewhat (again, relatively speaking) safer investments.
My cofounder and I were in the Summer 2010 batch and fit that description, and I know of founders in this summer's batch who do as well.
(Note: I first came to Hacker News by following links after reading Paul Graham's essays on education, e.g.,
http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html
from 2003,
http://www.paulgraham.com/hs.html
http://www.paulgraham.com/college.html
from 2005,
http://www.paulgraham.com/colleges.html
from 2007, and
http://www.paulgraham.com/credentials.html
from 2008, so my starting assumption is that some other people here on HN like to discuss education policy.)
What evidence is there that there are problems from increased class sizes? Several of the countries that best the United States in educational achievement
http://pirls.bc.edu/timss2007/PDF/T07_M_IR_Chapter1.pdf
have long had larger class sizes than the United States. For example, my wife grew up in Taiwan when the typical class size was 60 pupils in each classroom, and an unusually small class might have 50 pupils. But she had better primary and secondary education in mathematics and science and world history than I had (I supplemented my schooling with much independent reading of library books, which is the main reason I can keep up with her knowledge base) and she was going to school in a second language (her native language and home language was Taiwanese, but all her school instruction was in Mandarin) and attained strong proficiency in English by the end of high school besides. Small class sizes aren't so good if they match up many learners with less proficient teachers and curricula that are not well thought out. Better to have a larger class size, if that means being with a better teacher, and that's what the research shows about education policy. On the specific point of mentoring for start-up businesses, if the YC people know their craft, and it appears that they do, shared face time with them is better than much more undivided face time with at least some other investors. Choose your trade-offs if you are launching a start-up.
that's not the same arguments as a participant might use. it could be that you're going to start several companies in your lifetime; the probability of any one succeeding is not that great, but hopefully one will. from that point of view, what you want from YC is high quality contacts that carry across into future companies, even if those are not YC supported.
there's nothing to say, on the face of it, that those to mechanisms must pull in the same direction; the timescales are different, for example.