Your comparison assumes that the average lifetime of a hard drive is 1 month. I sure hope that's not the case!
Also, don't forget bandwidth charges if e.g. some of your s3 access does not come from ec2.
Also, don't forget bandwidth charges if e.g. some of your s3 access does not come from ec2.
You could add into the cost / GB of bandwidth to access the files, not as easy to factor into a TCO model in the personal use case.