Google threatens to pull Street View from Switzerland
electronista.com
electronista.com
The Swiss government is asking Google for an unreasonable amount of work in order for Street View to be allowed in Switzerland, and Google is saying they won't be able to comply because the request is, after all, unreasonable. That's all there is to it.
They specifically say that Google is, for example, free to charge users of Street View for access if they are unable to offer the service for free. The amount of work is only unreasonable in the framework of Google’s business model.
(I personally think that the algorithmic review is good enough, at least in this case, but I also think that this view probably doesn’t square with the law in Switzerland as it currently stands. Lobbyists, no lawyers, are needed.)
I happen to think the Swiss government is correct here, too. Privacy is a very real concern these days. I know there are some places where it is illegal to use someone's face commercially without written permission and they have to blur them out... Why should this be any different? Google has a service they are providing that isn't following that.
There are many places in this opinion where it is made very clear that the automatic process is not good enough and that additional diligence is necessary to protect the right of publicity of the photographed in a satisfactory way. Here is one example: „Vielmehr wären allfällige Persönlichkeitsverletzungen vermeidbar, würden aber einen finanziellen Mehraufwand für die Beklagten nach sich ziehen, weil sie die Bilder teilweise manuell unkenntlich machen müssten.“ (Violations of the right of publicity are avoidable but would lead to additional costs for the defendant because the photos would have to be manually blurred to some extent. This is in section 10.4.6. which considers the violations of the right of publicity and Google’s economic interests.)
By the way, this is not the Swiss authorities talking, this is a Swiss court.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Street_View#Privacy_issu... http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2010/05/wifi-data-collection-...
Swiss law defines personal data as „alle Angaben, die sich auf eine bestimmte oder bestimmbare Person beziehen” (all information that refers to a specific or determinable person), license plates clearly fall under this defintion.
Usually, personal data cannot be collected. The law names three exceptions:
1. Consent
2. Predominant private or public interest
3. A law
In this case, the court looked at the exceptions (especially the second one) and determined whether Google’s collection of personal data falls under them.
Which makes license plates as bad as faces when it comes to personally identifiable information.
[1] http://www.stva.zh.ch/internet/sicherheitsdirektion/stva/de/...