Legally yes you are right. Philosophically or morally I believe that copyright is based on a premise that is no longer the case.
I recently saw the Product Manager from Spotify give a presentation.
In it he said that spotify users are much more likely to listen to of the charts music when they use spotify. I think he said something like 60 or 80% of the music listened too wasn't chart music.
I seem to remember similar findings with netflix.
In other words when people have to pay for a CD or a DVD they will make the safe choice. But the second there are other options their patterns are different.
In my world at least. There is absolutely nothing philosophically or morally that dictates that it's a right to get paid for something that you can produce once and then mass distribute more or less freely.
It's an opportunity.
The movie industry has no problem replacing jobs previously held by people with machines. They have no problem arguing that people who used to do models with physical materials are just not effective enough. The movie and music industry have no problem distributing their content digitally, laying off thousands of people, closing thousands of stores. All in the name of the progress of technology.
And to be clear I have no problem with that either.
But I just so happen to believe that the same should apply for the record labels and the movie industry.
Just hanging on to old definitions of ownership while ridding themselves of others who aren't following the progress of technology is simply not grounded in anything but lobbyism.
So as long as those industries are not ready to re-considers rights issues while insisting that they should reap the benefits I simply refuse to accept that piracy is in fact piracy in the way it's claimed. I refuse to accept the philosophical premise that is used to define theft, illegal & copyright.
When the underlying reality changes so must the law and regulation. It's there to reflect reality, not the other way round.