From that day i haven't used any 2fa and just use password manager with additional backup.
From that day i haven't used any 2fa and just use password manager with additional backup.
this removes the "two factor" nature of two factor, but retains the one time password nature of one time password.
I honestly can't relate to people losing their access because something happened to their phone. The QR code is just a string of letters and numbers and you can save the QR code and the string of letters and numbers. I've been doing this for like a decade.
To use OTP I had to break out of that flow and start from a different part of the site.
But to add to this, I wouldn't ever set up a 2FA on a service that doesn't allow multiple second factors, and mostly static backup codes. Having only one (ie. device) is a much higher risk, of being locked out, than having the password stolen.
When looking at the actual attack vectors though it is vastly improved:
Mitigated - Online attacks on your account at any service
Mitigated - In person attacks on your account due to post-it notes
Mitigated - Losing your phone which was the only way you could generate a one time password
All this drama is mitigated, turning a disaster into a 5 second recovery.
Up until about 18 months ago I used to live in a part of the UK without any mobile phone coverage. So, any mobile number I had (with Vodafone) always expired after 3 months.
That does not make for any kind of fondness of places trying to blindly force SMS based 2FA on everyone. ;)
I have an encrypted backup of all my TOTP QRCodes and this has been tremendously useful.
I loathe sites that only do SMS 2FA, and I assume by default they just want my cell # for marketing or other privacy invasive purposes. Too many sites using SMS 2FA have poisoned the well.