Hacker News Reader

Does watching this pose a risk to being allowed to work on wine?

Just started part 1, but part 2 apparently shows the source code.

Edit: Part 1 is his personal journey of starting work at MS and how he got into making Task Manager. It's safe.

Edit 2: Actually not really anything in the way of source in part 2. But he promises code for part 3.

Part 3 shows the source code, in case you're concerned about it. It's just a few pages of C++ written 20 years ago, so unlikely that any lawyer would have any claim even in their wildest dreams, but stay clear of you want to have 100% plausible deniability. Parts 1 and 2 are clean.

ps: standard IANAL disclaimer.

Only if you believe in such things...

The risk is real. The only thing protecting wine and reactos from being sued to death by microsoft is that they can claim clean room design. If one of their watched a video explaining how windows works, it would make that defense illegible.

I guess it's more about the actual source code. I'd expect that just hearing "how" something works can still allow you to do a "clean room" in a sense that most of the algorithms aren't secret and a lot of "how" is obvious to the experienced practitioners just from the description of the behavior.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com