There's no question acquisitions are often botched. But you're
protected against the consequences of this if the acquirer is a
public co. I wouldn't advocate being acquired by a private co
except in exceptional circumstances.
Can you give us an example - under what circumstances would selling to a private company be a smart move?
The goal becomes to make it to the walkaway date with as little trouble as possible. To continue to manage "your baby" post acquisition is futile.
Hence, even managed quarterly, public co. is a better option for you.