The need for valveless masks was established months ago. Are people still arguing about this (aside from anti-maskers, etc)
Masks are better at preventing outgoing transmission than incoming so you’ve deliberately ruined the thing that a mask should be most effective as.
I don't think anyone is saying vented masks are ideal. Though they are probably better than most simple cotton masks, they aren't as good as an unvented N95.
A face shield without a mask is worse than just a mask.