I can think of these criteria on the top of my head: * trading volume * number of shops where it's accepted * whether you can pay taxes with it
Did you have something like that in mind? Or something else? What would lead you to say "this is not just a hobby currency anymore"?
For Bitcoin, transaction volume is not a good indicator of this because many of the trades (estimated >80%) these days are HFTs. Bitcoin is an asset for sure, but not a real currency.
Until then a bitcoin is like a call option or financial derivatives or really exotic instruments. Financially very relevant, heavily used, but so niche that it's of no relevance to basically everybody.
You might think this is a silly definition, because it means that the determination of how "proper" a currency is depends on where that person lives. And that's absolutely correct.
I have no functional use for Turkish Lira. The only reason I would possess any is because I'm speculating that the value of Lira will increase relative to the currency I use to pay for my needs.
Using that definition, one could create a Proper Currency Score by taking the number of people or businesses that use each currency and multiply it by the gross value of transactions performed in the currency (excluding currency exchange). This definition is at least reasonable on the surface, as the top currencies would be USD, EUR, and RMB.
Or if you’re in Turkey or Northern Cyprus.
If the OP wants a metric to use to gauge how "proper" a currency is, that metric should be primarily weighted by 1) how many people need to use it day-to-day, 2) the volume of goods and services transacted it in every day.
Hashcash, eGold and other similar pioneered the "dark ages" of digital money/value-transfer. Now we are in the ARPANET/Compuserve stage. Cryptocats and crypto-games is akin to "90s" internet. Next 10 years will bring really interesting thinks.
Bitcoin has been consistently "around the corner" from mass market for a decade now, while other technologies have been released and adopted.
do you even know how old bitcoin is?
Most have closed. The last one in use, Empire, had an exit scam this summer. Before that, Wall Street Market was taken over by feds and used as a honey pot - where they used traced bitcoin transactions to arrest dealers/people involved.
Any drug dealers still doing online trading prefer Monero, and even then, I would still say that using a currency solely to buy drugs online is the definition of hobby money.
Yeah actually.
If you think Empire was “the last one in use” you obviously have no idea what you’re talking about. There are more DNM transactions happening now than ever before.
There are closer to 20 markets in operation, XMR makes up less than 10% of the transactions. I’m sure many dealers would prefer Monero, but few customers do.
Most of the new ones that aren't invite only are suspected honey pots until they go a period of time without busts or exit scams.
You'd think that would be stupid because it's public, but so are blockchains.
APPL's market cap is $2 trillion and so by that logic it should be an excellent currency.
Second of all, just because US classifies bitcoin as an asset, doesn't mean the rest of the world has to agree with that. My country doesn't.
And from the wikipedia page of bitcoin: "It is a decentralized digital currency"
Bitcoin is not a bundle of securities, nor is an ETF a currency. Why would you confuse the two?
Just based on a hobby currency?
Being in an ETF does not make something a real currency. BTC is still hobby money.
GBTC has a $14B market cap. Do any Dogecoin ETFs? No?
Then maybe BTC is more than a hobby. It's a serious long-term store of value people are increasingly using as a hedge. A serious currency with commercial and institutional investors.
When you understand why Dogecoin doesn't have these things, you'll understand what a "hobby" actually is.
> BTC is still hobby money.
Can you post a single reason to believe that?
You keep listing characteristics of assets, like existing in an ETF or having a market cap or having commercial investors.
Those are not characteristics of currencies, which are widely accepted, engaged with, and in use by people and organizations in commerce.
> currencies, which are widely accepted, engaged with, and in use by people and organizations in commerce
So billions of dollars of institutional trading means BTC is widely accepted, engaged with, and in use by people and organizations in commerce. So, you said it's a currency.
That makes no mention of the consumer space, where I bought my widescreen monitor with BTC and pay my friends in BTC with PayPal. Have you heard of PayPal?
> BTC is still hobby money.
Can you post a single reason to believe that?
This is a straw man. USD is a good currency because it is widely accepted, engaged with, and in use by people and organizations in commerce.
BTC is not a good currency because it is not widely accepted, engaged with, and in use by people and organizations in commerce. Even in your paypal example, they first convert your hobby money to USD (a real currency) before commencing the transaction.
Having billions traded or invested in it is a characteristic of an asset, which you keep repeating, and not a currency. You're failing to understand this distinction.
Do you have a single reason to believe it's a hobby currency?