"I don't think any of that is true" is a strong statement. Nobody is saying that a toy renderer in school resembles a AAA rendering engine, but the point is that the thought process needed is the same, and I'm still going to expect a certain degree of rigor from any candidate. Also, the parent post is speaking more about the theory and fundamentals in general, not the direct contents of any particular coursework. FWIW, I am not formally trained in graphics or CS (my training was math).