WeWork: How the $3.5B Flex Space Giant Is Engineering a Comeback
sacra.com
sacra.com
Her “analysis” is just a smattering of positive events and suppositions, and she doesn’t address any he Elephant in the room. How can a renter make a profit by marking up the office space owned by real landlords? How go they prevent the landlords from simply repurposing their excess office space to directly compete with WeWork, without its overhead?
I still think it’s too rosy, but if we work can reset expectations that it’s a real estate company with those margins, and it’s valued low enough, maybe it makes sense.
I think there are a lot of plausible ways this can happen.
The core idea I think is, it's like colo/dc vs aws. Both make sense in different circumstances.
Higher pricing for flexibility, elasticity - avoiding lock-in while scaling up or down (maybe to 0) or moving location. Price transparency.
Network effects, brand recognition, standardised services and high quality "overlays" to spaces like wifi, printers and presentation equipment that works everywhere.
Social networks - in physical space, and improved discoverability of spaces themselves and related business clusters.
There is also a scale play where you get big enough as an intermediary to beat up suppliers - because you can control and direct demand. Usually a landlord gets to extract surplus value from a location but as WeWork's overlays / brand / network grow powerful they have a stronger negotiating position. Consider the situation where WeWork is huge, and having one near other properties you own (housing, food, retail, etc) raises the value of those.
You could take this further and who knows if WeWork will be the ones to do it, but there are definitely value improvements to be had over "negotiate with an agent and commit to an n-year lease, then do a fit-out". Serviced offices are a thing but scaling that idea _could_ be something else again.
My mental model was demographics. As an example, Apple users are "more valuable" than Android users. Not in any absolute or moral sense of course, just in terms of average propensity to blow money on things. In a bifurcated economy not all office occupants are equal value.
When I wrote that I had a model in mind where:
Your average WeWork occupant is more likely to be young, mobile, well-paid, renting an apartment, eating out, preferring "services" over owning things, and so on.
WeWork will be interested in tracking those demographics in ways that regular office lessors aren't, meaning they can tell that story and quantify the value they bring.
It's not a strong point (and it's a little sickening) but I think the rest of the argument stands.
Those aren't exactly his words; he says he doesn't get any information about the company from the stock price itself, and would rather develop an idea of the valuation and then compare it to the stock price.
https://youtu.be/BjSMeGprrkw?t=154
To be fair, maybe he said it differently in another interview or talk.
An example is he comes across a company with an excellent business model, that he would like to own. If he knows it’s trading at $10, when he does his DCF analysis he will need a valuation over $15. When he makes key DCF assumptions (growth rate, profitability, margins, lifetime of competitive barriers, etc) he is also subconsciously rooting for that > $15 result. It’s too easy to say, well normally I don’t think growth rates this high can last that long, but in this case the company is unique and special, so I’ll give it higher growth prospects than I usually find prudent, etc.
Go read his shareholder letters, you can find them back to the mid-70s online (and Buffett partnership letters back to mid 50s), and he often discusses his efforts to avoid bias (sunk cost fallacy, Mr. Markets influence, etc).
It simply does not make sense to me, for several reasons including the ones that you raised. It's such a common sense thing to me that WeWork would stuggle in a market abundant with vacant office space.
I almost feel like I'm shouting that the Emperor Has No Clothes.
---- What makes everyone think that corporate landlords facing unfathomable vacancies won't be able to hyper-aggressively compete with WeWork on short-term leasing, internet and amenities for tenants? They have much more leverage than WeWork does in terms of floor construction/reconfiguration costs. In such an environment, WeWork would not be able to lease and make money and would likely have to transition more of its portfolio to owned-properties, slowing its growth and subjecting the company to more risk...
Companies like Convene are much better suited to what's coming than WeWork is as suitable meeting space is likely to come at a premium.