A quick primer on the difference: https://lizerbramlaw.com/2019/03/06/fair-use-or-not-parody-v...
A quick primer on the difference: https://lizerbramlaw.com/2019/03/06/fair-use-or-not-parody-v...
From the ruling, quoted in the article:
> ’Boldly’ is not a parody. ComicMix does not seriously contend that ‘Boldly’ critiques or comments on ‘Go!.’
When most people think of parody they think of things like Weird Al Yankovic songs (as this article mentions), which definitely don't critique or comment on the songs they're based on - Eat It says nothing about Beat It; The Saga Begins doesn't have anything to say about American Pie. And of course it doesn't actually matter: somewhat famously, Weird Al actually licenses the songs he uses in his 'parodies', and doesn't rely on the 'right to parody' at all.
But the layman's meaning of parody persists. Weird Al's own FAQ says:
> Al does get permission from the original writers of the songs that he parodies. While the law supports his ability to parody without permission, he feels it’s important to maintain the relationships that he’s built with artists and writers over the years.
(https://www.weirdal.com/archives/faq/#:~:text=Al%20does%20ge....)
So it's maybe not surprising that there's a pretty broad cultural understanding that 'parody' means 'transforming something copyrighted in a way that's sort of funny'.
I mean, the Wikipedia article for The Saga Begins literally starts:
> "The Saga Begins" is a parody song by "Weird Al" Yankovic. It parodies "American Pie" by Don McLean...
But the law disagrees. It's not a parody in the sense of parodic 'fair use'. As far as copyright law is concerned, it's a derivative work, and Don McLean can dictate the terms under which Weird Al is allowed to publish it.
You haven't finished your documentation yet. Like:
"The value returned by detonate() depends on whether or not the method succeeded or failed."
Edit: clarification
Weird Al licenses his parodies, both the lyrics and the music, but additionally asks for permission from the singer/songwriter out of respect for the artists. Often the copyrights on both lyrics and melody are assigned to someone (or usually, corporate entity) other than what we think of as the “Artist”. He possibly (depending on the song in question) has a legal case for some of his lyrical parodies (Not so much “The Saga Begins”, but “Addicted to Spuds” is certainly a parody of love songs in general and “Addicted To Love” in that blast radius), but he plays the original melody, and that requires him to license his work.
Apropos but distinct: Figuring out the copyrighting entity, or if there’s a copyright at all, is itself a challenge: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_Birthday_to_You#Copyrigh...
[1]https://www.copyrightuser.org/create/creative-process/going-...
{1}https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=548277...
Weird Al is not simply adding any lyrics over the song but instead chose a long and convoluted story arc that awkwardly fits into American Pie's song structure. By including so much story detail from Star Wars into the song Weird Al effectively points out how ridiculous the profound but ultimately meaningless character archetypes are in the original song.
American Pie is filled with metaphors and allusions and is an impressionistic tale of the declining optimism of the sixties after the original exuberant promise of rock ‘n’ roll was lost in the plane crash that killed Buddy Holly.
The Saga Begins is a literal retelling of the story of The Phantom Menace - it doesn’t allude to themes or disillusionment or draw a clever parallel between the narratives. It doesn’t comment on American Pie or even on The Phantom Menace. It’s just a ‘humorous’ cross-cultural mashup of two copyrighted properties.
But that’s irrelevant, anyway. The point isn’t what I consider constitutes parody, but rather what the law considers as parody, which is specifically that if you are critiquing or lampooning a work, you are permitted to do so by borrowing from it and using elements that otherwise you would not be permitted to under copyright law.
Its intent is not to say that ‘anything that’s just intended to be funny is exempt from copyright requirements’, it’s specifically to prevent copyright owners from suppressing criticism of their work using copyright law.
So if you wrote alternative lyrics to American Pie that, for example, drew attention to the fact that its rose tinted view of sock hops and rock ‘n’ roll at the end of the fifties is rooted in a privileged white perspective, Don McLean would not be able to use copyright law to stop you publishing that.
But if you decided to just tell the story of a movie using Don McLean’s music, he is well within his rights to tell you you can’t (or come to a license agreement with you so that you can).
Weirdly, though, now that Weird Al has been there and done that, if you were to write an alternative set of lyrics to the Saga Begins that told the story of some obscure art house movie, say, parodying the way Weird Al used the song to just retell a movie plot... you might have a parody defense.
Quoting from that page (which I realize is just a synopsis and not a legal opinion): "In order to be fair use, a secondary use must transform the original by employing it in a different manner or for a different purpose than the original in order to produce a new expression, meaning, or message. A secondary use does not need to comment on or critique the original in order to be transformative as long as it produces a new message."
Is this really less transformative than painting a guitar and some face paint on someone else's photograph? Given that both cases involved overturning the decision of a lower court, clearly both sides are arguable here. It makes me wonder if this is really just a Circuit split, with different standards in different regions. Is there a canonical Supreme Court case here with national precedent that would unify these decisions?
Seuss > crowdsourced star trek
pictures sold for $8k total < paintings sold for $2M each
That said, I'd also be interested in an answer to heavyset_go's question. I think the answer is "no", and that it's only a case of "parody" being a positive example of transformation rather than "satire" being a negative. The decision in this case, for example, doesn't actually even mention the term "satire", and instead relies on the (not particularly well defended) opinion that setting Star Trek in the world of Go! might be transformative for Captain Kirk, but it is "not transformative" to Go!.
Campbell not only held that "Pretty Woman" by 2 Live Crew was fair use as parody, but also discussed the distinction of parody and satire: "Parody needs to mimic an original to make its point, and so has some claim to use the creation of its victim's (or collective victims') imagination, whereas satire can stand on its own two feet and so requires justification for the very act of borrowing." To some extent it simply codified a distinction already present in lower court decisions, but as the Supreme Court precedent it set the standard nationwide.
The case doesn't explicitly hold that satire is not fair use, or even that parody is fair use. Fair use is a case-by-case, multi-factor test that characteristically lacks bright lines. A "merely" satirical work that copied less of the original, or was extremely transformative, could be fair use. Parody and satire often co-exist and even "parody-ness" is a sliding scale that can affect the analysis. In practice though, Campbell is a pretty "bright-ish" line: if a commercial work obviously copies from an original, a court calling it "satire" as opposed to "parody" is almost certainly not going to find fair use.