Placebo-controlled trials for surgeries, as there already is for drugs, could do the trick.
Placebo-controlled trials for surgeries, as there already is for drugs, could do the trick.
For surgeries ? We actually cut someone open, then don't fix him, risking all the complications associated with anesthesia, infections and so on ? For drugs it's pretty easy to just give a fake pill containing nothing at all, you don't actually decrease then chance of survival.
And how does that work when the technique significantly changes, as in "in that case, do we cut above or below the knee". Again in the case of pills/injections, it's pretty easy to give everyone the impression they got all the same treatment, while in the of surgery you are pretty limited in that fashion.
Yes. There have been placebo-controlled trials whereby the control-group was just cut open, and left there for an hour. The placebo-patients believed they had undergone the actual procedure, and reported the same improvement as the actual patients. This is the placebo effect.
Although such trials are harder than giving fake pills, they might still be worthy of doing more often than we do now.
Placebo surgery trials would also benefit humanity a lot in better focused efforts, money and saving future patients from having to undergo useless surgery and take risks.
Somehow you imply it's ethical to try and fix a patient with a potentially sham surgery and risk complications, but it's unethical to do it with placebo thereby gaining knowledge that can save lots of lives down the line.
I guess it's a kind of trolley problem but have those been "solved"? Who decides if it's ethical or not? Why are they qualified to make such a decision?