Addendum: One benefit of this variant is that it is completely symmetric and hence completely fair. There is no advantage for either side because neither side moves first.
Addendum: One benefit of this variant is that it is completely symmetric and hence completely fair. There is no advantage for either side because neither side moves first.
Also, if you are going to write down moves, you can allow the players to move all of their pieces, too, like in Diplomacy.
A queen could capture a pawn next to the king, and a bishop could simultaneously move to prevent the king from capturing the queen, for example. A countermove could be to move a pawn between that bishop and that queen, and to have the king capture the queen.
⇒ I guess this multi-move variant would get highly complicated very soon. It might be better to follow diplomacy here and replace “If two moving pieces end up on the same square, both are eliminated” by “...same square, neither moves”, or maybe add “x supports y moving to square S”*?
There also is the possibility of simultaneous checkmate.
Another edge case is pawns taking pieces. Could a pawn move diagonally into a square being vacated by the piece standing there? Could two pawns simultaneously not take out each other (say by the simultaneous moves d4×e5 and e5×d4)?
Yes, that was part of the intent. There is game theory in play as well as chess strategy.
> There also is the possibility of simultaneous checkmate.
Yes, or even simultaneous king capture without checkmate(s) resulting in a draw.
Or you could adopt a quiddich-like rule and say that if the kings are simultaneously captured then the game is decided by the sum total of the remaining value of the pieces on each side.
> Could a pawn move diagonally into a square being vacated by the piece standing there? Could two pawns simultaneously not take out each other (say by the simultaneous moves d4×e5 and e5×d4)?
I would say yes and yes.
With no way to block or capture a piece on the square it's attacking from, the first time the king is placed in check he has to move or be captured. If the king isn't completely surrounded, the attacker only wins if they successfully guess where (or if) the king will move. The endgame would include an element of reading the other player, like poker.
Yep!
Note that it is also possible for the game to end in a draw if both kings are captured on the same move.