Recently I've bought a Kindle DX (used along with a relatively dim overhead freestanding lamp[1]), and I read that till I feel really sleepy. This satisfies my craving for reading instead of staring at a computer screen. The lack of a backlit screen shining into your retinas really helps!
[1] http://p.mdcd.net/product_images/full/2b3c568350aa9759eaa00a...
I've also "tried" everything and also feel the same when I get 2-3 days of very solid sleep in. A different person :) Strangely, I have had VERY good experiences with GABA, ZMA (both supplements, GNC etc.)Holy Basil extract (herbal pill). This combo really helps me fall and stay asleep more on Average versus most of anything else (including melatonin).
It helps as an assistant, not a knock-out Ambien like sleep aid, which I can't use if I want to be alert for work :)
I've adapted myself to sleeping when the clock says I should and not based on how well lit it is.