We will find another way to fund the internet. I have no doubt about that.
We will find another way to fund the internet. I have no doubt about that.
The important thing is to encourage mutual engagement and trust between sites and their users. Sites don’t currently need to do this because personal information stripping by the advertisers substitutes for it very well. Take that away and the relationship between authors and audience get pushed to the front, where they should be.
Obviously there are good reasons to have advertising, but we’re so far afield at this point, big changes are required.
Regulate it into the ground, and watch societies that don’t also do so, turn into slave nations.
I think "ban advertising" is a naive solution to an extremely complex problem. Personally I'm okay with advertising if it isn't intrusive. What I'm not okay with is manipulation, which is hard to pin down where you draw the line in the sand. And specifically the problem ads in this space are often impossible to differentiate between ads and naturally arising memes.
Still, I think banning advertising is a bad idea, even if I personally would be happy if I never saw a bit of advertising again in my life. It can perform a valuable function, especially if there's an underdog that is trying to offer a competing widget, say one that is more sustainable and also cheaper. Without advertising, I could see a large incumbent making it nearly impossible for this underdog to make a dent, which would harm customers of that product category.
In that case the advertising isn't "hey, I'm going to use psychology to convince you to buy this thing you don't have and don't really need" (the thing I object to), but "hey, I know you already buy this thing, but I'd like you to consider buying my version of it, which is objectively and factually better than the thing you're already buying". I think that is valuable information to get into the hands of potential customers.
But I just don't see a way of legislating away the psychological-manipulation types of ads while keeping the genuinely informative and useful kind, at least not without purveyors of the former finding loopholes to pretend that they're pushing the latter.
Where we draw the line could be where people make a business out of advertising. Those businesses would be illegal.
Word of mouth is good because it encourages businesses to provide the best service & value as that will directly affect whether they get referrals or not.
Phone book is also good because although it's similar to advertising, it's advertising that benefits both sides. The customer is in the market for a service and looks at ads from businesses that are looking for customers, unlike now where ads are pushed at you even when you don't actually need anything and distract you from whatever task you were doing.
There's no reason we can't have a modern version of the "phone book" where businesses can publish ads for a nominal fee (to pay for a background check to ensure they're legitimate) and prospective customers can then search through it.
Same here and now. Even if we did restrict advertising through laws, it would be a race to see who could advertise “legally” first, and thus suddenly capture everyone’s attention.
This would still resolve all of the issues caused by the current model of advertising, so I think it's worth it. Sure, it may make business more difficult, but so do the various safety regulations we already have; being in business is not a right and if your business can't be sustained without heavy advertising (which has negative externalities) then maybe it shouldn't exist?
- Buy the largest storefront in the most visible area, even if all you have is one product
- Create a shell company that creates directories, position it as “the best directory for <your industry>”, charge bleeding-high prices then give yourself adspace for pennies
- Good old fashion bribery: pay the lawmakers 10mil to put in a clause so that you’re allowed to advertise “in the header of your own site”, then buy a bunch of industry sites
Keep in mind that any solution has to understand that at the top of the heap there are companies making millions of dollars per month, and who are willing to spend whatever it takes to keep the revenue high