The pandemic is disrupting people's routines, not the lockdowns. The idea that society would be functioning as normal without lockdowns is silly.
The pandemic is disrupting people's routines, not the lockdowns. The idea that society would be functioning as normal without lockdowns is silly.
Given the large number of people disobeying restrictions, even in California, it seems that society would be quite a bit more "normal" if people were allowed to behave as they wished. See also how people flocked back to bars and restaurants when they reopened, how people have been crowding shops and malls, etc.
I'm sure some people flocked, but for example in my friends circle, nobody did - of course, that's an anecdote which is why the numbers would be needed.
A reasonable discussion has to start by accepting that every course of action is shitty here! The task is to weigh up the amount of shit and the different qualities of the shit down each pathway; it'll help nobody to claim that one pathway is shining and clean.
Fine, then mention both. The comment I was replying to blamed it all on the lockdowns even though the problem would exist without lockdowns.
> I think the more important point, somewhat ironically made on HN, is the critical effects of sleeplessness and promoting healthy sleep as a national public health priority. It seems to me this is just another pernicious example of how lockdowns and disrupting a population’s routines directly and indirectly damages public health.
Does this really blame it all on lockdowns? All I see is "lockdowns are damaging", which is certainly true whatever your political beliefs.
There is not even a hint in the comment that there is another cause to this disruptions besides lockdowns.
https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/pdfs/mm6932a1-H.pdf
Here’s a longitudinal study, showing that lockdowns were directly associated with increased depression in children:
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33298552/
Rates of depression in Wuhan decreased after the lockdown ended:
https://www.healio.com/news/psychiatry/20201112/anxiety-depr...
A study showing that rates of depression tripled during lockdown in the UK:
https://www.newswise.com/coronavirus/depression-and-anxiety-...
At some point, facts have to matter.