What is the macro explanation for this? Is health and housing in any way 2-3x better now than it was then?
What is the macro explanation for this? Is health and housing in any way 2-3x better now than it was then?
So, for the sake of argument, if an average workers salary had stayed exactly in-line with inflation, house prices could've gone up 4.2x and they would have spent about the same amount of their monthly expenses on the loan per month. Lots of caveats that make this not as true in practice though (taxes, ability to refinance in the future at a lower interest rate, etc.).
[0] https://www.macrotrends.net/2604/30-year-fixed-mortgage-rate...
I’m going to go with 1990 for a specific date. According to their source, house prices have gone up 2.6x since then.
In 1990 the prevailing mortgage interest rate was a little over 10%. Today its about 3%. For a house that costs the exact same amount, the payments today are 2.1x less. Conversely, the same payments today let you afford a house that costs 2.1x more.
Additionally, as far as I can tell, that figure isn’t adjusted for inflation, which is 1.99x since 1990.
Combining inflation and more affordable payments, an equally affordable house would today cost 4.2x what it did in 1990. Seeing “only” a 2.6x increase, the inflation adjusted monthly mortgage payments are almost 40% lower today. For the down payment, however, the easy credit doesn’t help you, only the inflation, so a median inflation adjusted down payment is still 30% more expensive today.
That’s my best guess for macro explanation. Cheaper credit and inflation.
The median house price doesn't appear to have been adjusted for inflation or median income. So the factor of 2.4 times isn't quite as high as it might first appear.
The size of a median single family house has also grown. Most people prefer to have more space, and are willing to pay more to get more.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/456925/median-size-of-si...
Health care expenses have increased for a variety of reasons. Baumol's cost disease is one factor: most healthcare work can't be automated (yet) and we have to pay the providers more every year. Americans on average are getting older, sicker, and fatter. New treatments have been developed which can extend the lives of some of the sickest patients but at an extremely high cost. In the past 25 years we've improved the 5-year cancer survival rate by around 8% but spent a fortune to accomplish it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Average_Indexed_Monthly_Earnin...
Furthermore, with things like housing, we get major distortions of real world meaning that are completely obscured by macro trends. For example, the average housing price across the country has outpaced inflation metrics by a little, but if you narrow it to places of economic opportunity, it has drastically outpaced inflation. Any new growth in economic opportunity has been accompanied by even more severe growth in housing costs. The end result is that average housing prices appear flat-ish relative to income, but it has stayed that way due to massive emigration of economically disadvantaged people away from areas of economic opportunity.
What has really happened is that America fell in love with dysfunctional markets. Free market prices, but with significant regulatory capture. We've got cartels on housing via hyper-localized land use regulation that decreases the relative supply of housing.