My first synthesizer was a Juno 60, and I owned a bunch of other vintage and modern ones over the years. With hardware, it was a whole ritual to turn everything on, each instrument had its own smell, it put me into a mood of "let's play with this machine and see what happens".
When I moved to software, I finally had all the sounds I always wanted but could never afford, I finally no longer had to futz around trying to reprogram a patch I liked, I finally could send any instrument to any effects box... but there were less happy accidents. It felt a bit more like my day job, which also just involves sitting in front of a computer.
I think it can be like that for a lot of people, where the tactility and limitations of the gear can inspire a different approach to music-making. I imagine that aspect also plays in to the emotion that some people have that hardware instruments "sound" better.
All that said, I would never go back to hardware. As you say, it's hard to beat the convenience of a laptop.
With a VST, everything goes through a mouse. And you'll probably spend some of your time getting distracted by moving windows around to show/hide other VSTs.
It's a much more cerebral experience.
My biggest problem with software is that it's so limited. VSTs and DAWs ape hardware studios far too literally.
I'd like to be able to connect anything to anything - including VST internals to the internals in other VSTs. And add some generative/programmed elements. But most DAWs either don't allow that at all, or they only allow it with severe limitations.
I’m excited to see what happens in VR. The tactile feedback isn’t there, but I bet the muscle memory is. I don’t have a VR setup, but Synthspace might convince me to get one this year—it looks better every time I check on its progress. A VR modular synth kit without the insane cost? Yes please!
Yes, but there's also noise inside the Juno at the DAC, chorus, etc.