(FWIW I’d love to be wrong, so please share any optimism.)
There's cause for optimism! Basically, it'll take a big chunk of 2021 to vaccinate everyone (at best), immunity may take a while to kick in, and while vaccines may be 90ish% effective, continuing to follow transmission reduction measures will help further mitigate spread while COVID is still prevalent, so keep it up for a couple months after the bulk of people start receiving vaccines. Not amazing, but also not indefinite, and I believe this has been the messaging for quite a while now.
I'm not sure what you're asking. Do you think vaccines won't work, just because Fauci is advising caution even after you get one? That's good advice until society has widespread immunity, and it has nothing to do with the efficacy of the vaccines.
Surely the reasoning is “since the vaccine is only 95% effective, it is prudent to exercise caution until we reach herd immunity, because you might be one of the 5% who aren’t immune”. But clearly that does pertain to the efficacy of the virus, so I don’t think I understand your meaning.
You're right, it's partially that and partially the fact that you need two doses and potentially 2 weeks or more after the second dose to hit that 95% effectiveness. I was more responding to the idea that "maybe the vaccine isn't effective at all" which it seemed like the poster above might have been hinting at. Which doesn't make a lot of sense, because the article they linked pretty clearly lays out the rationale.
Ah, that makes sense. Thanks for clarifying!
How will we know we've reached it without people taking off masks and gathering in groups? It's also worth mentioning herd immunity depends on r0, and r0 changes when behaviors change.