> But it's not necessary to down talk where we're at to motivate improvement.
It is necessary if the general perception of where we're at is much better than where we're actually at. I think the U.S. still has a very strong cultural air of superiority which perhaps is no longer justified (if it ever was). The first step to solving a problem is to realize that it exists, and the U.S. educational system is only recently coming under scrutiny because of repeated criticisms of it.
> Students come out believing they can do anything.
I'm uncertain about this -- both whether it's true, and whether it's beneficial if true.
> They're not afraid to try new approaches.
Actually, there's a growing murmur of dissent that, at least in the special case of "gifted" children, the constant praise of their intelligence leads to a fear of failure which, in turn, leads to a fear of trying things which others might try without hesitation.