Yeah, Matrix is great. I was probably among the first people to install Riot, but the grim reality is nobody (well, one geek-friend of mine and his wife) uses Matrix. Look, even I was surprised when you mentioned "Element": thought it must be some new messenger I didn't hear about...
But I'd surely rather like people to promote Element here, not Signal.
I demoed it recently as a Slack alternative and it's not very user friendly. Our groups ended up just using Signal.
Also I've previously had the Android app crash and throw Java stack traces, but that was an older version.
That's how e2ee works. You have to send all the old messages to other new client on your other device.
2. Technical lingo like "verify other session" and some buggy emoji shenanigans confuse people. The only passable device linking, based on scanning a QR code, is between Element Desktop and Element Mobile, but...
3. Element on iOS is absolutely awful. The worst interface I've ever seen. Extremely busy and convoluted. Rows of horizontally scrollable icons, duplicated as lists? Chat views where spacing is all off? It doesn't work for small group chats and doesn't work for large public chatrooms.
4. Element on iOS won't play GIFs. Element on Chrome/Electron only uploads the first frame of a pasted GIF. This was actually a deal breaker for my social circle.
Frankly, just compare the user experience of Keybase and Element. Keybase got it right.
Note that this isn't just theoretical - there are governments using Matrix, but not necessarily federating with other instances.
I don't know if any other competitors who do the same. As Signal messages are end-to-end encrypted, Even if their servers were compromised, your messages would still be secure. As they use a rotating key, unlike manually using PGP, even if one of the keys was intercepted, they would not be able to decrypt any of your other messages. Using PGP, if someone steals your private key, all your messages are now vulnerable.