I'm unfamiliar with this; are you bitter about a lack of attribution that they produced lots of the IP their GPUs are built on?
I'm unfamiliar with this; are you bitter about a lack of attribution that they produced lots of the IP their GPUs are built on?
"Apple expects that they will no longer be using Imagination’s IP for new products in 15 to 24 months."
But at no point in time did Apple announced they stop supporting PVRTC. Nor did they make any depreciation notice.
That announcement caused IMG's stock price fall by nearly 80%. IMG was later sold to a Chinese VC. ( Which somehow had some tiny connection linking to Apple, but that is in the conspiracy field so I wont go into it )
And if you look back now, Apple were not telling truth or lying by omission.
Which is what got me to scrutinise every details when they had a battle with Qualcomm. And it was a very different view to what mainstream media tells you.
[1] https://www.displaydaily.com/article/press-releases/discussi...
From reading this, I'd be mad at the bogus/flimsy stock market (and the restrictions on behavior it imposes on companies to satisfy ever more greedy stockholders) rather than Apple here.
Tangentially, it's far easier to be an ethical underdog than it is to be an ethical winner. But Apple isn't even trying.
Of course, when companies are large enough, shareholder's interests spin off into the regulator's domain, allowing interesting turn of events in the form of bailouts
But there's a significant economic cost to society when large companies fail catastrophically like this. Which is why size matters. Large companies mean putting all of our economic eggs in one basket, which is exactly what systems like capitalism are supposed to avoid.
Reviving a corrupted entity to allow it to continue must have a cost that needs to be weight against the perceived loss of its benefits.
Apple took Qualcomm to court due to 4G/5G patents dispute. And made number of claims which were false, possibly inaccurate or lying by omission.
I initially sided with Apple, quoting Tim Cook
“Despite being just one of over a dozen companies who contributed to basic cellular standards, Qualcomm insists on charging Apple at least five times more in payments than all the other cellular patent licensors we have agreements with combined,”
Fives Times More than others Combined. That is ridiculous. We knew Qualcomm were expensive, but we never had an actual number or up to date figure. This allegation was repeated in all mainstream newspaper and website. There were at least Six other major companies ( Nokia, Samsung, Huawei, ZTE, Ericsson Intel/LG ) with broad wireless patent portfolio. That is Qualcomm = 5x where other companies = x/6. Or 30x difference if x were divided equally between all companies.
This got people furious. And I did too. Despite knowing Qualcomm have the best, this kind of multiple were unheard of.
That is until you sit down and start to run some numbers. It doesn't make any sense. You can add up the low end, high end estimate of all there other six companies patent licensing cost in their investor notes and rounding to the nearest number and it would still be an order of magnitude off the figure Apple were trying to paint.
Apple argued Qualcomm made double dipping because they were earning profits from Qualcomm Modem itself, and they are still charging for patents. As if the design of the Modem itself doesn't cost anything?
And numerous other claims.
At the end instead of going to PR battle with Apple, Qualcomm has shown immense restrain. I guess they knew they would win. And since then I have tremendous respect for their CEO, Steve Mollenkopf's professionalism.
The only person who bother to report all the fact from both side was Shara Tibken from Cnet. Who actually sit in every Apple Qualcomm trial ( There were multiple ) and tweet as well as post update. You can read about it here [1] to make up your own mind.
[1] https://www.cnet.com/news/apple-and-qualcomm-settle-heres-wh...
I know it's business but they seem a pretty bad customer by most standards.
People don't have to interact with that side plus the public image is super polished.
TL;DR: What you're saying seems perfectly in character.
If you wanted to use one QCOM patent, you'd have to pay for a suite of patents that includes IP you have no interest in using.
If you want to use a particular technology, the pricing would depend on the total price of your handset -- even if the difference in handset price has nothing to do with the Qualcomm technology.
Their business is tough because they basically spend years inventing technologies and then more years licensing them and defending their IP in court. Still, if you have to draw a moral/ethical conclusion I'd suggest that (at least in part) Qualcomm brought its 2016 Apple woes upon itself.
> Apple's has already been recruiting Imagination workers for months, its most prominent get being COO John Metcalfe. Until now, hires were being sent to Apple's main offices in London, or overseas to California.
> The company now has over a dozen listings for graphics-related jobs in South Hertfordshire, the region in which St. Albans and Kings Langley are based.
https://appleinsider.com/articles/17/07/10/apple-sets-up-off...
Edit to add quotes.
I remember the IMG stuff being full of bugs