Corporations should not have more power than the elected officials.
Corporations should not have more power than the elected officials.
They don't control his voice. They just control if their resources are used to magnify his voice.
The alternative is state-directed media where the leader directs what political messages must be relayed and private parties have no choice about whether to relay them. That's not only inconsistent with the First Amendment, it tends to work out badly.
A state controlled twitter is an interesting suggestion. I am not sure that's a better situation.
The alternative is that the government protects the liberties of its people and protect against the tyranny of the majority.
PS Facebook Twitter Google Amazon Apple ARE the state media at this point. For now!
I see this almost in reverse, that why on earth has the US Federal Government put a company like Twitter in this position? The Feds have their own communication apparatus and instead foisted onto Twitter the responsibility of being the primary communication channel of the president. He has other options but he fully embraced Twitter and despite profiting from it, it's also not entirely fair to them.
Same with the Russian disinformation. There is a ton of state sponsored fake Twitter bots that the Twitter staff is fighting constantly. Why is that on them? Shouldn't the Federal government be fighting that as part of protecting the country?
I'm a little surprised a blog hasn't already sprung up on whitehouse.gov.
Indeed, they have to police their platforms to avoid wrongful death suits, and keep advertisers happy.
edit: And to be honest, this is no different then all the "Google shutdown my business for no reason" posts we see on HN. The conventional wisdom there, is "don't build your business on third party infrastructure/services. I'd think the same logic holds for politicians. Hell - they have they're own TV network (c-span) - why don't they use it more ?
No, because that's not something that could actually ever have happened. Nothing that crowd could have done, or was planning to do, would have actually resulted in any of them "taking over" the government, that's not how this works. That asshole in the buffalo costume got his two minutes of internet fame and then got arrested.
4 people did die for Trump during this ‘boomer chimpout’. What makes you think more would not have been willing to get involved if it looked like it was building traction?
Also, they planted bombs in the DNC and RNC, and look - petrol bombs: https://www.justice.gov/usao-dc/pr/alabama-man-charged-posse...
We should be far more worried that Twitter gave the president a free ride for so long, violating their own standards to allow a powerful person to violate them. That's the real threat to freedom.
Twitter has given and continues to give people just as or even more deranged than Trump free rides. They don't care, because either a) they agree with those people or b) censoring those people could give them bad publicity and could hurt their ad revenue.
Meanwhile, people like Trump get banned all the time because their politics are okay to ban according to the advertisers/investors/media/population Twitter wants to please. Trump himself stood this long because, even if the people twitter wants/needs to please hate him, his tweets made them money—even from the people who hate him, who nonetheless hang onto his every word—by virtue of being the president of the USA and thus having far more reach than the usual "right wing nutjob".
Twitter waited until now to ban him because in their calculations, I presume, losing less than two weeks of money that Trump's insane stream of thoughts might give them is compensated by the good publicity of this making them look righteous in front of everyone else.
Sadly it works, even here in HN everyone forgets the usual narrative of "these corporations are evil, let's break them down and/or regulate them more heavily, and, for the love of God, let's stop their sinister spying on us", and starts defending these monopolies like no tomorrow as soon as they censor/ban someone they don't like. Even if it's a completely meaningless gesture like this one.
There are many problems with corporations and capitalism to be address. Being generally ‘anti-corporate’ just isn’t useful.
The Left opposing the Right’s efforts to commandeer corporate resources to serve right-wing political agendas and demonize (and incite violence against) those insufficiently subservient to right-wing interests against the will of the corporations involved isn't “cozying up to corporations.”
What part of this indicates that the government has authority over who Twitter chooses to allow on its platform?
That crossed a line and that's why he was banned.
Facebook and Twitter are important communication channels for the public.
It's dangerous that they can ban any elected official without going through any single legal process. No judge. No jury.
What we are doing here is a screaming match. Who can scream at Facebook/Twitter the loudest probably wins. This is going to turn into threats on FB/Twitter execs very quickly. You'll see.
Why can't we have a due process for banning elected officials?
That's why I ask for a due process like what we have with our justice system.
You and I are free to criticize FB and Twitter. As I mention, now it depends on who screams the loudest.
Let me get this right. You are against having a due process for banning elected leaders from a popular communication channel? You prefer we scream at each other until one wins? Really?
A person was using a privately owned website to encourage people to go commit acts of violence against senators and congress representatives. That website did not want to be complicit in that violence so they removed access to those people.
Eg. If you go into a coffee shop and start smashing windows and beating people up and rallying for people to murder each other the coffee shop doesn’t need “due process” to kick you out and ban you.
There are laws that exist and twitter has a terms of service. There’s no due process needed. If anything Twitter should be criticized for not banning Trump sooner. They let him do so much damage and allowed it to get to this point for ad revenue and engagement. I’m glad they finally did something but frustrated they allowed it to get to this.
Then, the leader of that riot should go to jail for 25 years for murder, not simply "banned from coffee shop".
Also, in a real situation, employees would first keep themselves safe and call police to handle the matter.
In your imaginary situation, would you ask your minimum-wage employees to handle violence in the store?
This is my point exactly. Twitter should just follow the law. If Trump breaks the law, then get a court order to remove him or call the police.
Dorsey and Zuck shouldn't play police.
Also, who's screaming? Just search on twitter. Dorsey and Zuck has been called Nazis, white supremacists, racists for not banning Trump.
That’s not how freedom of speech works.
Judge can definitely order you to remove the comment.
Also, an author's blog is not a popular communication channel like Twitter.
Yes, I'm asking for a proper process of removing an elected leader from an important communication channel like Twitter.
If the POTUS is banned from NBC, surely they can still get their TV messages out, right?
And if someone is not satisfied, we should just scream at Dorsey until he caves.
Your twitter account is not a product. The product is sold to advertisers. And even the ads they will or won’t show has guidelines they are not legally forced to show ads that would incite violence.
The legal argument being made in multiple threads about freedom of speech like this demonstrates that you all know literally nothing about freedom of speech or what it means
The shop owner wouldn't be the one who judge and come up with punishment. The justice system would do that.
That's my position. Twitter is an important communication platform. And there should be a due process for banning an elected leader.
Let's go with the president/senates of the most powerful country on the planet first.
Ultimately, we should apply to every official leader of every country. But that can come later.
Yes, we can get the court order (or whatever it is, I'm not familiar with the name) to forbid Trump from using Twitter.
We do this all the time while performing investigation (e.g. forbidding a person to travel after making bail).
http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2009/04/have-you-ever-legali... (skip to "credit card buckets")
When twitter was launched, would George W Bush have been granted a non-suspendable account on day 1?
Should Biden get a non-suspendable Parler account on Jan 21?
Would the members of the House of Representatives also be non-suspendable or is that for Senators only?
California is larger than many countries by many measures. Should California's elected leaders have the same privileges as Italy's or the Netherlands'?
"It doesn't sound hard to figure it out" hides a lot of complexity which needs to be dealt with. To me, it actually does sound fairly hard (or labor-intensive at a minimum) to figure it out to a level of detail required to pass a law.
Let's just start with the most powerful person on the planet first, which POTUS, on the most popular social networks, which are FB and Twitter.
We don't need to figure now what to do with, for example, a senate from Namibia.
My position is that, if we are gonna ban an elected leader, let's get a judge to issue a court order.
It's the same thing with search warrant or the arrest, and we can do that in a timely manner.
The problem that I see is that nobody is pushing for having a proper process at all.
Also, our tax law is like 100x more complex than this. So, yeah, it doesn't sound hard.
They let Trump get away with a CONSTANT stream of bullshit and insults over the last four years. Their PR people had to constantly engage the media to tell them that he only kept his account because he was POTUS.
He isn't gonna be POTUS much longer, there are about 40 other platforms he can use, and he's got an entire press apparatus.
I'm tired of this revisionist nonsense. Again: Trump and others would have been banned A LONG TIME AGO if they weren't elected officials who spent money on these platforms according to their TOSes.
Almost all of what I see on there is magnitudes worse than anything I've seen Trump post, and yet there's no action against those users...
This is clearly partisan politics. The ban hammer is not applied equally.
I see unbelievable insults, direct calls for violence (from both sides), acrimonious, spiteful and hateful posts - with zero consequences.
But Trump posts "go home peacefully" and he's banned?
I don't know about you, but I've actually spent a lot of time reading Trump's Twitter feed. While I'm personally embarrassed about his lack of executive poise, and I disagree with most of what I've read, I've never seen anything that would come close to a call for violence, or many of the other things he's been accused of.
Happy to read examples if you have some and I've just missed it.
Stop thinking about political parties, and think about individuals, their role in society, their influence and the consequences of their actions.
Sending a mob of radicalized people with mental issues to kidnap senators is a bad decision and he got rightfully punished for it.
Yes!
I'm not familiar with the situation.
Can we have a due process like our justice system to assign blame?
Should I just take your word (and the word of trump opposition)?
Also, isn't it weird that, you claim, he is the leader of the riot into Capitol, and the punishment is being banned from social media??
Should this be like jailed for life or something?
You get a police to arrest the aggressor first and get them to court.
We can simply get a police to issue an arrest, ban him from social network, get him to court later.
I don't think this problem is particularly hard. Not sure why a lot of people seem to think that this is impossible to resolve through legal system.
Trump is leading the riot/coup. He should be arrested immediately, no? (In some countries, that's a death sentence.)
It's either (1) Trump isn't really leading the riot/coup or (2) leading the riot/coup isn't unlawful.
I'm confused on this contradiction of reality. Somebody is lying here.
Can you please show me specifically where he did this?
If not, it may be time for you to take a break from politics as well, and try to view the situation objectively.
I'm very open to having my bias, if any, pointed out. If you can show me anywhere where the president did what you claim, I'd be very interested.