For the NASDAQ, I get a 12.57% ROI over the last 30 years. It went from 372 to 12999.
For Berkshire I get a 13.96% ROI over the last 30 years. It went from 6750 to 343525.
So around 1.5% more for Buffet. Still a close call, when you think about that he is the symbol for a great investor and put his whole life into valuation research.
Even if the average investor could reproduce this performance ... do they have the funds to make it worthwhile?
The lesson might still be: Don't try to valuate stocks. It is not worth the time.