Railways were going to decline because we spent a half trillion dollars building a competing highway system, which had several distinct advantages:
- by and large highway travel in the US is not charged a toll, which makes the per-mile marginal cost much easier to deal with
- highways are not charged property tax and railways are. Many a railroad during the decline ripped out tracks and electrification to reduce the value of their property and to goose up their balance sheet before potential mergers.
- in addition to not paying tolls, the amount of subsidy for highways from the general funds is much higher; compare that to Amtrak, which is so poorly funded a lot of its trains don't run more than once a day.
- minimum parking regulations are pretty much everywhere in the United States, and the requirements are generally much higher than what's needed, so last-mile is not a problem for cars; you have to arrange a journey to and from the train station
The main difference between here and countries that survived a railway decline is the absolute lack of interest from the government in keeping it alive. Amtrak was founded by Nixon with the intention of letting it die.