It's easy to take this position when you're very tech savvy. Imagine how many billions of less tech savvy people these kinds of blocklists are protecting.
It's very easy to imagine a different kind of article being written: "How Google and Mozilla let their users get scammed".
On the other hand, lots of chrome users most likely do trust google to protect them from phishing sites. For those ~3 billion users a false positive on some SaaS they've never heard of is a small price to pay.
It's a tricky moral question as to what level of harm to businesses is an acceptable trade off for the security of those users.
I'm a fan of google doing their best to protect people from scammers. The real issue here is no way to submit an escalated help request when they accidentally mess up. eg they could build a service where -- and I doubt scammers would play -- $100 (or even $1k) would escalate a help request with a 15 minute SLA. I run a business; we would have no problem paying an escalation fee.
"How Google Runs a Pay-to-Play Protection Racket"
Format your site to suit google, or they don't index it.
Add headers to your emails or google reduces deliverability.
Pay for clicks on your own company's name or google sells ads against the name of your company! They monetize navigation queries.
Run your site through amp and let google steal your traffic or google pushes your search rank down the page.
Let google steal answers to questions contained on your site and display them as answers w/o sending people to your site, or they deindex you (see tons of examples, but also genius).
Let google steal your carefully curated and expensive photographs for google shopping and use them for the item from other vendors or you can't list items in google shopping.
etc etc etc... it's nothing new. So we may as well encourage them to do a more helpful job of what they were going to do anyway.
Uh, it kind of did, when internet-savvy early adopters (and developers) convinced all their friends, then family, then acquaintances, to switch to Chrome a decade ago.
I know there's probably a very large number of FOSS-only types on this site who would disagree with that assessment, and claim that they've always been in the Firefox camp, but the sheer market share of chrome clearly shows that they are the minority.
Everyone switched to chrome because they were tired of IE having too much power and not conforming to standards. Nowadays web devs often build chrome-first, using chromium-only features, and the shoe has almost migrated to the other foot.
Because they run a popular browser and don't want their users getting scammed?
For each tech savvy person mad about this, there's 10 non-tech-savvy people completely oblivious that could get scammed by phishing sites we'd consider obvious.
Sure, they should do a better job, but that blacklist is probably millions of websites big at this point. It's the kind of thing where a perfect job is essentially impossible, and the scale means that even doing a decent job is going to be extremely difficult.