> everything that can be talked about by humans, in principle, should be considered
> at the reach of symbolic approaches
This doesn’t seem obvious to me — do you have any references that support this idea? > everything that can be talked about by humans, in principle, should be considered
> at the reach of symbolic approaches
This doesn’t seem obvious to me — do you have any references that support this idea?If you read War and Peace, and I read War and Peace, even if our experience of the reading might be slightly different, it will be due to how we react to it, and to which passages we tend more attention; and we will generally agree on what Tolstoy wanted to communicate - not only on the words themselves, but on the world constructed, and the implications of it that are not explicitly described.
Another way to look at it: we don’t have any evidence that we need more than a symbolic approach to replicate what we do with language: and we have built a whole civilization based on written education, which is based in symbols.
To me, if you can operate on a model that you use to understand a bit of the world, serialize it into communication, and make it so that the other understands it, that evidences intelligence, but I agree that it is not a demonstration.
I have not read Marcus’s book and I don’t follow him a lot, but I think that they are also advocating a mixed approach.
War and Peace is like a textual Xray of Tolstoy's brain, some of it being descriptive of what he saw while writing it. If our models are similar enough, together we'll see the same things he saw while we read it.