I've seen shit like this in every field...
"Books every historian should have read."
"Books every English professor should have read."
"Books every psychoneuroendocrinologist should have read."
They're all a collection of shit that someone, somewhere - usually with an inflated self of self - feels qualified to tell you and every other person that they should have read.
You know what you should have read? Papers you find interesting that advance your understanding for the problems you face. Understand I'm not saying that every list everywhere is a load of horseshit that you need to ignore - I'm not. I'm saying be wary of all-encompassing "lists" of "things" you "should" do / know / read / experience.
EDIT: LOL, stealth edit on the title... from "Papers every computer scientist should read" to "Syllabus for Classics of Computer Science".
Well... at least the pretension took a backseat. :)