Gregory,
I think their response is one of the things making the situation worse. If I understand correctly the reasons for keeping it are:
* If documentation isn't generated automatically, where is the incentive to write documentation?
* It's useful for newbies because they can start up `gem server` or use `ri`
So, incentive. Really? I can tell you that of all the code I've written the number of times I've documented it with YARD or RDoc because of a fear that it would be auto-generated on each client and they'd see that is was found wanting is precisely... zero. I document my projects because I want people to use them, I don't want my inbox filled with questions on how to use it, and so I can link to somewhere like rdoc.info where potential users can read it online. I just don't buy that the auto-generation is working like a big scary stick making developers write docs.
As for newbies, I doubt many genuine newbies have any idea of how to use `ri`. Even if they did, you have actually know the class/method you want. At best it's a reference, it's awful for just browsing around trying to piece things together yourself. What I suspect most newbies do is go to Google and enter "How to open a file in ruby", they don't `ri File.new`. The latter assumes a reasonable (albeit forgetful) knowledge of the API, you can assume they're more likely to know about --with-ri rather than the newbies knowing about --no-ri.
The problem here really is that there is a not-insignificant number of people who have all put this setting into their .gemrc file because they want it as the default behaviour. Is it a representative sample of the community? How can we find out? It certainly feels that rather than find out the support for this addition was deemed a "circus of +1's", ignored, and closed.
I makes it had for me to feel sympathy towards the project, reluctant to offer any changes I'd throw around for consideration, and grateful to see others take the initiative to actually fix the problem (you with your mediation, and then SlimGems as a possibly viable alternative).