What I still remember from that page was : 1) Hand-made 2) Scarity (in a good way)
I just checked your website and 30 seconds after I don't remember anything about it.
The challenge is how do you add more products while keeping complexity to a minimum. We still want to have a clear message to someone that lands on our page but now they have more options as to what they can buy on our site. I guess it is a bit of a trade off.
When I do the test myself on your website :
1) REX RAY DODOCASE 2) DODO Case - Protects From Extinction 3) Couldn't tell in less then 5-10 seconds
Is that really what you want me to remember ? Also, my comment apply to "Acquisition", repeat customers is another matter.
PS : Sorry for my poor grammar/syntax, english isn't my first language.