> Upon information and belief, Robinhood’s actions were done purposefully and knowingly to manipulate the market for the benefit of people and financial intuitions who were not Robinhood’s customers.
And even then, there aren't enough other facts in the complaint itself for me to feel comfortable justifying discovery. For example, they never mention that Robinhood allowed only sales, instead alleging that Robinhood disallowed all trades with GME.
The best route plaintiffs have to win the lawsuit is to argue Robinhood's illegality here. They don't do that effectively in the complaint, which hurts their case (though they could, and probably should, amend their complaint accordingly).
If Robinhood is doing what they claim, ie: is having issues fulfilling orders and/or is legitimately trying to protect retail investors by limiting purchases of a volatile asset, wouldn't it be worse if they prevented people from selling as well as buying? Is there some detail I'm missing that makes only limiting buy orders "blatant" proof of market manipulation and not the best possible option they had if they were acting in good faith?
Note: even if my counter argument here is correct, I don't think that necessarily means nothing fishy going on since there are a lot of other questionable factors at play and even if they were acting in good faith within the "stock market game" that doesn't mean the game as a whole isn't rigged.
My understanding is the forum members were colluding to drive up the price of particular securities? How is that not manipulation?
Although I guess I would have preferred the relevent stock markets to step in with a complete trading halt on those securities if intervention was required.