Hacker News Reader

Comment by MaxBarraclough | Hacker News Reader

I support Free Software, but I don't find those instances to be convincing. None of them really illustrates an issue with power and control.

> I would be better served if I quit my music addiction on proprietary YouTube.

Would you be better served by a Free Software alternative, or is the issue with your overconsumption of music?

> Some would be better served with a paper todo list than proprietary Google Tasks– which lost several of my todo items.

Data-loss bugs are a serious issue whether or not the software is Free.

> Robinhood's users may have been better served not buying stocks at all.

What does that have to do with it?

View on HN

> Would you be better served by a Free Software alternative, or is the issue with your overconsumption of music?

The issue is the proprietary algorithms of YouTube are designed to addict me to music, creating an overconsumption of music.

> Data-loss bugs are a serious issue whether or not the software is Free.

Dead trees and Emacs org-mode are both resilient against data loss.

> Dead trees and Emacs org-mode are both resilient against data loss.

How so? Emacs isn’t magic. It’s software. It has bugs. Countless things can cause data loss with paper—-rain, sweat, literally losing it, bad handwriting, wear and tear.

> the proprietary algorithms of YouTube are designed to addict me to music

Seems to me the interests of the user and the provider are pretty well aligned here. A good recommendation engine lets the user enjoy more music, and keeps the provider in business. I don't mean to sound unsympathetic here, but addiction isn't a common issue with music streaming. There's a reason it isn't regulated the way online casinos are.

> Dead trees and Emacs org-mode are both resilient against data loss

Dead trees are not resilient against data loss. They're clumsy to duplicate and are easily lost or destroyed. Emacs is just a text editor. There are plenty of relatively bug-free text editors, both Free and non-Free.

Again though, I support Free Software, but don't see how these examples illustrate issues of power and control.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com