Their profit is not the measure of what they extract
Their total top-line income is the proper measure of what the HC Insurance companies extract from the system -- PLUS the entire income of the set of companies that optimize billing so that providers can get fully paid -- PLUS the entire income of the industry of seminars & trade shows teaching providers how to optimize their billing, etc., etc., etc.
That entire industry of HC payments is parasitic - it adds no value, and extracts money.
Just pay the providers, and have patients show up at the door to get care, and let the doctors be the gatekeepers, not some unqualified insurance bureaucrats.
And yes, there would be many, many thousands of HC insurance workers who would need to find new employment. This is a good thing.