I want bank transfers with a progress bar like in the movies. And if you interrupt the transfer before it's completed only part of the funds will be transferred.
The progress bar should also have ominous music like those films where the infiltrators download the contents of the secret stash of info from the computer onto some driver while the clock is running out on them being discovered.
They do this by taking on the settlement failure risk, which is exactly what Robinhood does, and is exactly why Robinhood ran into potential trouble when GME became so volatile.
Give me safety over freedom, says every hegemonist when putting words in our mouths.
Your corner case scenario should not determine behavior for the market. That it is used to excuse behavior that is rammed down our throats anyway is, well, inexcusable.
I tried to be generic about who was adding the delay. I’m always short on time. Sorry if I missed a detail there.
Another way is to admit that we, as humanity, have very low tolerance to situations where people acting in good faith lose money to fraudsters through no fault of their own.
This is not "corner case scenario". This may not happen much, but the tolerance for when it happens is very low. The systems are designed with that low tolerance in mind.
A fairly easy way to add fraud protection would be to have T-0 or instant settlement only for previously used accounts/routing numbers. A lot of services already implement this on their end such that new bank accounts take a few days or a week to transfer but future transfers appear instant or within a day. Other options include allowing the first $X-thousand to be instant and the rest settles in T+2. This is pretty common if you get automatic deposits over a certain amount or use a phone check scanning feature.
I guess my point is that a lot of edge services (services that people interact with) already cover the T+2 delay in their own manner but that leads to confusion when some middle service provider decides to change the rules. Making the system itself adopt those strategies would just distribute the risk not increase it.
By all means allow users to set such delays if they want them, but the technology enforcing T+N really isn't a feature for customers so reframing it as such is probably a bad approach.
Furthermore, if there was instant settlement the idea of “shorts” changes: you could still borrow a stock but it is super clear who is holding it at a given moment, and how many are held by whom.