The problem isn't with Android per se as the Nexus S is clearly giving him a good user experience. It's just no longer a cutting edge device and the newer devices he's tried aren't delivering a usable whole product.
Maybe.. I would have been tempted to try an iOS device or even a WP7 after the second Android before going back to out-dated technology though.
Maybe some of us just really like the way the Android OS works, and can't stand the limitations of iOS and WP7...
You're not supposed to say things like that around here...
Fair enough. Down voted for a legitimate suggestion. HN really going downhill fast.
I believe that both of those choices would have been even more "out-dated", though.