It was scorned because they basically skipped phase 3 testing and started injecting people. The fact that it worked after the fact Doesn’t make it any less reckless.
I don't think that they acted recklessly. In a critical emergency situation you need to be willing to take a level of risk and to balance that risk against the cost of not doing anything or of delaying doing something. From what they knew a priori about the type of vaccine (coronavirii are known and that's also what made development of vaccines quick) and the positive first trial phases they made a decision. I don't think it was a particularly risky decision but still they made it.
In fact, adverse reactions have already been tested for in previous phases. Phase III is all about effectiveness. In a pandemic it seems rational to do this testing quickly. Its defensible to do it in public trials.