For instance, in English we pronounce the letter μ as "mew" ([Mju]). In modern Greek, μ is pronounced "Me" or [Mi] (spelled as μι). Here is a YouTube video of a Greek person going through the alphabet, linked to μ. [1]
However, it's thought that "mew" is probably closer to the Ancient Greek pronunciation (Wikipedia shows the Ancient Greek phonetics as [mŷː] where ŷː is like "few" [2]).
More to the point, though, the English pronunciation of Greek letters was fixed around the 16th century (see [3] for a tiny bit of history) and was an attempt to use the classical Greek pronunciations, though probably not a very successful one.
Likewise π is pronounced differently in modern Greek, where it pronounced like "pee," not "pie," and so would make π-day a very different holiday...
1. https://youtu.be/P85PXR6deIw?t=214
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mu_(letter)
3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pronunciation_of_Ancient_Greek...
Plus, no one really knows what the "classical" pronunciations sounded like. We can make some educated guesses from the tonal symbols that older Greek used to use to guide pronunciation, but that's all.
Most differences on pronunciation that your stats professor has been complaining for could just be accounted by normal differences in phonetics by people trying to casually pronounce some Greek words or letters.