I appreciate the feedback (rereading the site I can see the confusion), but I think concluding this is “doing poorly as a startup” is a little premature and something you can’t accurately judge, especially since from your submission history it looks like you have little in the way of a successful startup background when this field is very much a learn by doing one.
This is closer to a roboadvisor than those niche hobby brokerages. The massive difference is those all have incredible barriers to entry - knowing how to code, or at least knowing how to build a profitable automated investment strategy. These are all turnkey, transparent, and no code customizable. Regular investors can use these, only a few can properly take advantage of those you listed. Most of my users came from Fidelity, Schwab, Betterment, and so on. Not Quantconnect (though plenty have come from there and others).
Compared to roboadvisors: these models are more far more innovative and diverse. Use crypto or quantitative strategies made by professionals or curated from other users instead of standard stock bond allocations. Even innovative roboadvisors like m1finance only go as far as hedge fund followers. The difference is huge - the goal here is to be your platform for higher risk and higher return investing, for the 15-20% of your portfolio you want to go further at the risk of larger drawdowns.
I was where you were on my entrepreneurial journey recently, so my best advice is just to do. “10x improvements” and other academics they teach you in SUS is super useful (and often true), but until actually applying the learning, finding what works for you in the current market, you’re just repeating catchphrases without understanding them. You likely won’t even understand the magnitude of an improvement until you do your research and try things out, so best to focus on that when your idea has been validated first.
For your reference: this scrappy site with no optimizations, no contact, no how it works, no fluff, has already garnered several millions of $ in pledged user investment, has profitable and repeatable acquisition channels with an on page organic conversion rate of a large fraction of visitors, has collected thousands of data points, surveys, and interviews towards product market fit and all aspects of the model from target customers to revenue streams, and all this only a few weeks (late December) into prelaunch. I added only what was important to my preexisting library and put it out there. All my research and customer feedback so far suggests that this is a magnitude of improvement, and many are desperate for a platform like this.
Hope that clears it up and thanks again for the feedback!