I recently tried to appropriately set the FOV of first person shooters to match the FOV that the screen actually took up. I found that most games would not let me set my FOV that low, even when I was 1-2 feet away from a 24” monitor.
It seems strange that it is given that people want a wider FOV than is natural. It gives a competitive advantage in the majority of scenarios, but I’m surprised more people don’t stop and think “this looks off”.