> You'd end up arrested and jailed at some point.
- assuming they didn't flee
- assuming they didn't spend the bitcoin
- assuming they didn't transfer the bitcoin, and then claim it was stolen/lost.
With fiat controlled by banks, most liquid assets are frozen during these sorts of disputes for the above reason. A threat of jail in the future also doesn't really help the other person during that timeframe.
Cash does magically appear, actually. It's printed by mints and released via monetary control.