> imagine if keeping your car idling 24/7 produced solved Sudokus you could trade for heroin
> imagine if keeping your car idling 24/7 produced solved Sudokus you could trade for heroin
Thats just a failure to understand the value proposition of bitcoin. Its a medium of exchange that has a hard limit on inflation, no greater fool required. Hence, the comparison of ice cubes and fiat currency.
Edit: this (older?) article says 4.6 transactions per second and a propagation (read: transaction) time of 14 seconds. This is with near-zero percent of transactions in the world taking place in btc. https://hackernoon.com/the-blockchain-scalability-problem-th...
Thats something people will have to decide for themselves.
> Considering the energy cost and environmental consequences this article references, we'd need the ice anyway.
Don’t worry, when it melts they will make more.
- That's what governments do with fiat money.
I think you may be conflating recent bandwagoners with enthusiasts.
“There’s a limit to the number of bitcoin but the government can print as many dollars as they want” is a value proposition that bitcoin enthusiasts are likely to be familiar with.
It seems presumptive to think that this entire enterprise is being sustained by ideological purity and noble goals, rather than a ton of people interested in trading a valuable (in fiat!) asset, facilitating capital flight from restrictive regimes, attempting to justify Tesla's stock price, etc. Occam's razor would suggest more people are driven by the profit motive from bitcoin than actually realizing a utopian future.
We have plenty of data, we have the discussions and promotion efforts surrounding bitcoin where the contrast between the hard cap on bitcoins and the continually depreciating fiat currency was a prominent selling point.
> It seems presumptive to think that this entire enterprise is being sustained by ideological purity and noble goals, rather than a ton of people interested in trading a valuable (in fiat!) asset, facilitating capital flight from restrictive regimes, attempting to justify Tesla's stock price,
Its not really ideological purity to be aware of the fact that one asset is designed to depreciate and another asset is not. Its just basic fundamentals. Why would enthusiasts and bandwagoners sink money into bitcoin in order to support tesla’s stock price? That sounds like a conspiracy theory.
> facilitating capital flight from restrictive regimes
Thats certainly another value proposition that appears alongside the hard cap on units.
> than a ton of people interested in trading a valuable (in fiat!) asset
Why would a ton of people be interested in trading an asset? What indication do you have that they are unaware of the implications of the asset trending higher and higher relative to fiat?
> Occam's razor would suggest more people are driven by the profit motive from bitcoin than actually realizing a utopian future.
Doubtful. The simplest explanation is that they are purchasing based on the stated reasons that people have purchased up until now. Your alternate hypothesis is more complicated, so Occam’s razor does not suggest this.
The best promotion for BTC is simply its price, the ease of setting up a Coinbase account, and mooning memes of $100k/coin.
> Why would enthusiasts and bandwagoners sink money into bitcoin in order to support tesla’s stock price?
Tesla, currently less than 1% of the global auto market, is worth more than several of the largest automakers combined. Musk pushing "to further diversify and maximize returns on our cash that is not required to maintain adequate operating liquidity" by buying into an asset which is currently in a bull cycle is a good way to attempt to justify that price.
> Why would a ton of people be interested in trading an asset? What indication do you have that they are unaware of the implications of the asset trending higher and higher relative to fiat?
Simply compare the price of BTC now to where it was a year ago, and take a look at its trajectory on the chart.
> Your alternate hypothesis is more complicated, so Occam’s razor does not suggest this.
Animal spirits are self-explanatory.
https://qz.com/1971100/buying-bitcoin-after-an-elon-musk-twe...
How is the astronomical price a promotion? People want thing when they can get them for less, not pay a record price for them. If you think bitcoin is a good deal at its current price then you must believe there’s some underlying fundamental that makes it worth tens of thousands of dollars.
> the ease of setting up a Coinbase account, and mooning memes of $100k/coin.
There’s no value proposition to having a coinbase account except acquiring cryptocurrency. One doesn’t even need to hold btc to post or enjoy memes. These have little and nothing to do with the cause of the high price.
> Tesla, currently less than 1% of the global auto market, is worth more than several of the largest automakers combined. Musk pushing "to further diversify and maximize returns on our cash that is not required to maintain adequate operating liquidity" by buying into an asset which is currently in a bull cycle is a good way to attempt to justify that price.
That explains why Musk would buy it. That does not explain why anyone else would buy it.
> Simply compare the price of BTC now to where it was a year ago, and take a look at its trajectory on the chart.
Obviously, if there weren’t fundamentals, now would be a good time to sell.
> Animal spirits are self-explanatory.
Animal spirits are an unnecessary hypothesis for this event.
Because people are expecting it to get to $100k, which means it's a hot commodity in a speculative bubble. Not everyone who buys into a bubble believes that the underlying fundamentals justify the price in the long run- they just believe that there's room to grow, and that there are greater fools to sell to.
> These have little and nothing to do with the cause of the high price.
Just like the ease and lack of fees of Robinhood spur more stock-buying, Coinbase makes trading crypto easy and facilitates more bandwagoners who further pump up the price.
> That explains why Musk would buy it. That does not explain why anyone else would buy it.
I brought up that reason with Musk in mind. And Tesla buying it has direct second order effects- it popularizes and legitimizes BTC and cause more to buy into it, whether they're familiar with the underlying intentions of BTC or not.
> Obviously, if there weren’t fundamentals, now would be a good time to sell.
People buying in now believe there's still room for the price to rise. An asset with solid fundamentals (Tesla stock, GameStop call options) can also be wildly overvalued. I'm sure similar conversations were happening in 2018.
> Animal spirits are an unnecessary hypothesis for this event.
Look at the market. Look at the economy. Everything is animal spirits now in search of yield.
Zirp explains exactly why asset prices are inflating, as I said before, animal spirits are an unnecessary hypothesis.
> Because people are expecting it to get to $100k, which means it's a hot commodity in a speculative bubble. Not everyone who buys into a bubble believes that the underlying fundamentals justify the price in the long run- they just believe that there's room to grow, and that there are greater fools to sell to.
When there are underlying fundamentals, as in the case of bitcoin, its not necessary to speculate on why people might buy a thing otherwise. Certainly there are people who buy because its trendy. Thats not really relevant though.
As for it "not depreciating," I claim that's because people believe it should go up, i.e. BTC is worth something (meaning you can exchange it for USD at a favorable rate) because people say it should be -- by fiat of the speculation market rather than fiat by a central backing agency. If it were only worth something because it "didn't depreciate," it BTC rises would correlate strongly with inflation. Since there's been essentially no inflation since BTC has been created, that's obviously untrue.
I would also take issue with the assertion that it is, in fact, scarce. Scarcity means nothing when you literally have something that is arbitrarily subdividable.
PS, the USD is also "ledger money." Well over 90% of USD only exist as bits in a computer system. It's essentially the same as a private blockchain.
So that allows it to be a medium of exchange with a stable number of outstanding units, which is an improvement over USD.
> Why should I be transacting using a record of someone's solution to a useless math problem to begin with?
People who want to transact don’t wonder why they need an exchange medium.
> As for it "not depreciating," I claim that's because people believe it should go up, i.e. BTC is worth something (meaning you can exchange it for USD at a favorable rate) because people say it should be -- by fiat of the speculation market rather than fiat by a central backing agency.
Why should anyone care about your opinion on btc? You don’t even seem to understand why a currency should be scarce (in the economic sense).
> If it were only worth something because it "didn't depreciate," it BTC rises would correlate strongly with inflation. Since there's been essentially no inflation since BTC has been created, that's obviously untrue.
Obviously, you’re mistaken about inflation.
> I would also take issue with the assertion that it is, in fact, scarce. Scarcity means nothing when you literally have something that is arbitrarily subdividable.
“Scarce” here refers to the economic sense of the word, not its common analogue.
> PS, the USD is also "ledger money." Well over 90% of USD only exist as bits in a computer system. It's essentially the same as a private blockchain.
This would be a good opportunity for you to reflect on why USD are decreasing in value while BTC are increasing.
And why should anyone care about yours? You seem to be operating under the extreme naiveté of someone who believes that the massive presence of bandwagoning speculators, would-be manipulators like the Elon Musk/Winklevoss billionaire cheerleaders, Chinese miners buying massive amount of asics, various schemes such as Tether, are irrelevant to Bitcoin. A currency is subject to real world conditions and influence by real-world actors. It's not a system that can exist only perfectly in a vacuum.
> This would be a good opportunity for you to reflect on why USD are decreasing in value while BTC are increasing.
You can say the same of $TSLA, $GME, or any other meme of the moment. Why did BTC increase in value in 2018- until it didn't?
No reason at all, thanks for the reply.
> You seem to be operating under the extreme naiveté of someone who believes that the massive presence of bandwagoning speculators, would-be manipulators like the Elon Musk/Winklevoss billionaire cheerleaders, Chinese miners buying massive amount of asics, various schemes such as Tether, are irrelevant to Bitcoin.
Not at all.
> You can say the same of $TSLA, $GME, or any other meme of the moment. Why did BTC increase in value in 2018- until it didn't?
Price != value.
As well, I'm not questioning the need for an exchange medium. I'm questioning why a certificate that says someone solved a useless math problem is a valid exchange mechanism.
> Why should anyone care about your opinion on btc?
Apparently you do, just not enough to be civil about it. If I had to speculate as to your motivation, I would say that it's because my point of view is dangerous to your interests. That is, if everyone thought the same as I did, BTC would be worth $0, just like I claimed in an earlier comment.
You also claim I don't understand inflation, but don't care to explain it to me. Well, here it is: inflation is the result of too much money chasing too few things. That's it, nothing else. As I've mentioned, that's also the reason the price of BTC climbs relative to USD. More people want to buy BTC with USD than they did yesterday. It's as simple as that. What you don't seem to understand is that the value of a currency is relative to the things people want to buy with it.
Let's illustrate the point with a hypothetical. Suppose a magical genie snaps their fingers and suddenly, everyone's USD bank balance gets multiplied by 10. What happens then? People still value the things they were buying with USD yesterday the same, so, prices will just go up by a factor of 10. You can call that the USD depreciating, or you can call it the price of goods increasing. Those things are equivalent.
See, the whole problem with your argument is that BTC only has any value whatsoever with respect to USD and other currencies. With fairly limited exceptions, you can't buy things with BTC, so it's not exposed to the true value of things one would theoretically buy with it.
One final question: do you take issue with my statement that the USD essentially is a blockchain-based digital currency? If so, how? If not, why bother with BTC?
Oh, and you still haven't explained why BTC should be worth anything at all. I thought you were one of those "enthusiasts" who understood those things? Is there a reason you don't want to explain it to me so I can become an enthusiast as well?
In this case, the value is as a unit of account that is (mostly) guaranteed to be, not just scarce, but have a hard limit on quantity. This links back to your first sentence, and people’s desire to be able to make several transactions or hold funds without depreciation.
> As well, I'm not questioning the need for an exchange medium. I'm questioning why a certificate that says someone solved a useless math problem is a valid exchange mechanism.
This also connects to your first paragraph. The simplest answer is that value is subjective and the people using it value it for that purpose.
> Suppose a magical genie snaps their fingers and suddenly, everyone's USD bank balance gets multiplied by 10. What happens then? People still value the things they were buying with USD yesterday the same, so, prices will just go up by a factor of 10. You can call that the USD depreciating, or you can call it the price of goods increasing. Those things are equivalent.
This is a good example. Now imagine what happens if when the genie snaps his fingers, all the white people in NY, DC, and SF have their bank balances multiplied by 10 and the rest of us don’t. What happens to prices of the things white people in ny/dc/sf buy? What happens to the profits of people who sell to them? What does the market look like for the rest of us, who are now competing with people who have 10x as much money for the same goods? Do you see now how the FED’s actions distort the economy and cause certain people to benefit to the detriment of others?
> One final question: do you take issue with my statement that the USD essentially is a blockchain-based digital currency? If so, how? If not, why bother with BTC?
USD are an electronic ledger but they aren’t a blockchain. BTC are desireable because of the hard cap on the number of units, which means that a person who holds BTC is protected from the risk of their currency being diluted by additional units.
> Oh, and you still haven't explained why BTC should be worth anything at all. I thought you were one of those "enthusiasts" who understood those things? Is there a reason you don't want to explain it to me so I can become an enthusiast as well?
Tbh I’ve explained it a few times and I’m not convinced that you’re actually interested in understanding. You’re spending a little too much time inferring things about me (incorrectly, mind you).