But if you've been mining bitcoins since the beginning, you probably have a lot. Now mining is no longer very profitable because more people are in on it; thus, it makes sense for the early adopters to convert their bitcoins to USD at Mt Gox. They make a load of money from the late adopters, and the late adopters are left with loads of worthless bitcoins (because eventually nobody wants them and you can't sell them). Sounds more like an MLM scheme.