Only roughly comparable: if you line them up back to front you can see the whole notch of the mini behind the 5.
That doesn’t seem too bad. The notch is not meant to hold interactive elements.
I can use a 5 one-handed.
The mini I cannot.
And its probably going to go away and future minis sidelined, as its sales are poor.
I feel like the story would have been different if they made it the size of the 4... Right now the “mini” would have still been considered a large phone in the 3GS days.
That would make things even worse. A lot of people only use smartphones for computing and they want large screens. Making the screen even smaller would have doomed the mini even harder.
Also, the smaller you make it, the smaller the battery is. The mini already has battery life complaints. This product would likely be doomed if it was any smaller and didn't compromise on other things.
Doubt it just yet. People aren’t moving yet, people lost jobs. So if the market properly recovers, it will stick around.