Konrad Zuse's Z1 was first: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z1_(computer)
Even if you want it to be electrical, not mechanical, then Zuse's Z3 was first: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z3_(computer)
Konrad Zuse's Z1 was first: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z1_(computer)
Even if you want it to be electrical, not mechanical, then Zuse's Z3 was first: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z3_(computer)
The prehistory of computing has a bunch of really interesting machines like this (and Colossus, and early ENIAC really) which are technical marvels, but miss at least one of the key things which make a computer really a computer.
People often focus on the electrical vs mechanical distinction, but that's a red herring. If you made a 386 out of Lego, it would still be a computer. Similarly, binary vs decimal is irrelevant.
To me, there are three key characteristics:
1. There is a program comprising a sequence of symbols which are interpreted by the machine (so not Colossus or early ENIAC, which were controlled by plugboards)
2. There are symbols for conditional branches, or some equivalent construct, and the language is Turing-complete, or some practical projection of it (so not the Z3, ABC, or ASCC)
3. The program is stored in a memory which can be modified by the program
Once you have those things, you can do anything. The first two points are the most important, but i think the third is also really significant: it is what allows things like operating systems and linkers to arise. If the first two are the definition of life, the third is the definition of multicellular life.
The program should be in some kind of more-or-less addressable memory, to support conditional branching. That's all.
Most today are far more powerful than any among the whole first decade of practical computers. Those ran compilers in as little as 4k words of memory. The output of the compiler was not written to memory; it was punched directly to tape or cards. (On some, it physically could not be written to program memory, even if there were room: no bus connected to there.) The tape was later read into program memory--often onto a spinning magnetic drum--and executed directly, no OS in sight.
If you imagine these were not practical computers, consider that people paid $millions for them; they earned their keep. Have you ever operated a computer doing work worth that much?
This is incorrect. The Z3 is Turing-complete, as has been shown by Raúl Rojas in 1998 [1]. It requires some hacking though.
Moreover, the technique in the paper is purely a stunt. You couldn't do practical branching computation that way. It is definitely cool, but it doesn't change the fact that the Z3 was a calculator, not a computer.
[1] http://www.inf.fu-berlin.de/inst/ag-ki/rojas_home/documents/...
You can always play the "who was first" game if you just add enough distinguishing categories.
The invention isn't much of an invention until the whole thing is electronic. Reading off a tape doesn't cut it. That's why, you'll notice, the entire computer industry bloomed out of the work done on the ENIAC. In other words, if your client had invented facebook, they would have invented facebook.