Marcuse-Anon: Cult of the Pseudo-Intellectual
taibbi.substack.com
taibbi.substack.com
And, the rights and freedoms that let the proletariat have a non-horrible life is therefore something to destroy, so that the proletariat will then have a reason to revolt? Yeah, um... "They eagerly seek you, not honorably, but they desire to shut you out in order that you may seek them." (From the Bible, actually.) Anyone who follows Marcuse in this is a friend of revolution, but not a friend of the human beings that the revolution is alleged to benefit.
Marcuse's point was that material goods, and the system that optimizes that freedom, comes at the cost of other freedoms, in particular of political dissent, autonomy, and freedom from total administration of the state. It would be better to consider the point Huxley was making as closer to what he was getting at. Marcuse tried to synthesize Marx's sociology (while maintaining that Marx's classical economic analysis has been superceded in modern capitalism) with Freudian social psychology.
>And, the rights and freedoms that let the proletariat have a non-horrible life is therefore something to destroy, so that the proletariat will then have a reason to revolt?
No, this was never Marcuse's argument. Instead he argued that not only are the majority of workers better off materially, within capitalism this comes at the cost of the loss of revolutionary potential. For Marcuse, the availability of goods in capitalism was one of its strong points, but the alienation and libidinal repression of workers was not. Marcuse did not argue for destruction, but rather for individuals to consider for themselves what are 'true' and 'false' needs.
In other words, Marcuse thought there were problems with capitalism which are not captured purely in terms of the material wealth in Western countries. Marcuse was not very quotable, but this quote of his points to his rhetorical style:
> “If the worker and his boss enjoy the same television program and visit the same resort places, if the typist is as attractively made up as the daughter of her employer, if the Negro owns a Cadillac, if they all read the same newspaper, then this assimilation indicates not the disappearance of classes, but the extent to which the needs and satisfactions that serve the preservation of the Establishment are shared by the underlying population.”
> No, this was never Marcuse's argument. Instead he argued that not only are the majority of workers better off materially, within capitalism this comes at the cost of the loss of revolutionary potential.
I fail to see the difference between "they don't have a reason to revolt" and "loss of revolutionary potential". Given who you are, I suspect that you're using the second term in a technical way. Could you define it, or expand a bit on what you mean here?
> In other words, Marcuse thought there were problems with capitalism which are not captured purely in terms of the material wealth in Western countries.
I agree, actually. We have fed the body, and left the soul starving. (Is this what Marx meant by alienation?) It's better than people physically starving, but it's still not good enough. I doubt that revolution is the answer, though, nor changing the means of production. It seems to me that the problem is that people are expecting material prosperity to satisfy them, and it doesn't. Merely changing the means of production isn't going to fix that.
People, according to Marcuse, are more readily able to see the problems of the system when they are on the outside and the margins, and being on the outside usually entailed a lower standard of living, low wages, and soul-crushing work. Marcuse thought that there are serious problems with capitalism, ones which may be reason for revolt, but increasing material security and integration into the system in which the worker becomes part of the machinery of the establishment (sometimes quite literally in lock-step with the machines or even a particular brand of machine) leads to this conversation not arising. He argued that contra Orwell in which "war is peace, peace is war", the contradiction is hidden in the noun itself by unintentional ideological forces. This precludes even most conversations about freedom, never mind critique.
The point is that people should have revolutinary potential even if they deliberate and decide not to revolt. I should have the potential to read a book, even if upon reflection and consideration using that potential I decide to watch a movie instead.
He argued that the modern system and the state, with its educational system, dull critical thinking or fail to nurture it in the first place. People have fewer options, including the option to revolt. In Repressive Tolerance he argued that because these potentials and critical abilities have been dulled, core democratic functions of deliberation cannot meaningfully be carried out any more.
The point probably also applies to, say, the Soviet system, its integration of the people into its state machinery, its totalizing ideology, and its propaganda which precludes informed deliberation among the majority of people.
One thing, though:
> He argued that the modern system and the state, with its educational system, dull critical thinking or fail to nurture it in the first place.
I don't disagree. But before the modern educational system, did something do better at nurturing critical thinking? I could see saying that, for example, the New England 1700s education produced critical thinkers, but that's a very small region. Did, say, the education system in 1890-1915 Russia produce better critical thinkers? Or pre-1848 Europe? Somehow I doubt it.
Or is the idea that, say, from 1900 to 1950 the education system produced critical thinkers, but the "modern" (post 1950) system does not?
When was it better than this? It's not good, sure, but when was it better?
It's a problem if being a revolutionary is part of your identity, as it invariably is (by definition!) for the radical left and most likely also the radical right.
(As an aside, how can an article about Marcuse and *anon revolutionaries not mention Fanon? /s)
If you want to read about Marcuse's actual philosophy written by someone with an expertise in philosophy rather than a blogger with an axe to grind, check out the article on him of The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy here: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/marcuse/
In any case, I did read the entire article, and I submit that Taibbi provides good enough proof on the pseudo-intellectuality claim. Here's a passage he quotes from Marcuse, on the "tyranny of affluence"
> The systematic moronization of children and adults alike by publicity and propaganda, the release of destructiveness in aggressive driving, the recruitment for and training of special forces, the impotent and benevolent tolerance toward outright deception in merchandizing, waste, and planned obsolescence…
When aggressive driving is offered as the terrible outcome of the tyranny of affluence, requiring suspension of basic civil liberties and freedom of speech, then for me at least there's sufficient proof that Marcuse has both feet firmly planted in BS territory.
As for your second claim, that the excerpt doesn't prove Marcuse's influence, I think your case is stronger here. Thankfully, you provided a link from "someone with expertise in philosophy", and I will quote literally the second paragraph:
> The Frankfurt School has had an enormous impact on philosophy as well as social and political theory in the United States and around the world. In the 1960s Marcuse ascended to prominence and became one of the best known philosophers and social theorists in the world. He was often referred to as the Guru of the New Left (a title which he rejected). During the late 1970s through the 1990s, Marcuse’s popularity began to wane as he was eclipsed by second and third generation critical theorists, postmodernism, Rawlsian liberalism, and his former colleagues Theodor Adorno and Walter Benjamin. In recent years there has been a new surge of interest in Marcuse.
"enormous impact on philosophy as well as social and political theory" "Guru of the New Left" "new surge of interest"
As an aside, I note with amusement that an article, questioning the intellectual foundations of a social movement seeking to restrict free speech (and has already achieved much "success" in this area), has been flagged so as to reduce discussion. Bravo, very appropriate!
I would have appreciated a hint of how he will prove it in the article rather than just name-calling and requiring a subscription to see what his actual point is. I've noticed that the tactic of writing about someone (especially social theorists and other thinkers of more marginal theories) extremely uncharitably is a hallmark of accusations that rely on the reader not being acquainted with the thinker, the thinker's context, or the subject matter more broadly. Look at what the NYT did to Scott Alexander for instance. This excerpt is far worse and far more uncharitable to Marcuse as a person and his intellectual legacy. You don't find attacks like these in good-faith discussion.
>requiring suspension of basic civil liberties and freedom of speech, then for me at least there's sufficient proof that Marcuse has both feet firmly planted in BS territory.
This is not a sign of being a pseudo-intellectual; the fact that he has a political position you disagree with, or reasons from a premise you do not think holds does not make him a pseudo-intellectual. Marcuse's actual essay makes a more convincing case concerning democracy and J.S. Mill's justification for speech on functional grounds, and where it may falter. The partial case against freedom of speech has nothing to do with aggressive driving.
Further, what can we say about someone's legacy and status as an intellectual on the basis of one essay? Surely it matters what he wrote both before and after the essay too. For sure it's unpopular, but there is room for reasoned disagreement. A bad argument does not a pseudo-intellectual make.
A more convincing (but still lackluster) argument would be to say his use of psychoanalytical theory made him a pseudo-intellectual, but unlike some of his peers, he did not use obscurantist language, nor did he bury his ideas beneath several unnecessary layers of abstraction. Marcuse stands up extremely well against others given the label of pseudo-intellectual such as Lacan or even Zizek.
>"enormous impact on philosophy as well as social and political theory" "Guru of the New Left" "new surge of interest"
None of these specifically relate to Marcuse's essay on tolerance, which is the issue under discussion. I don't deny that Marcuse was popular for the main body of his other work, but my point was that there are theories against freedom of speech today which are not only generally more convincing than Marcuse's, but real drivers behind the movement to curtail speech. Few people use Marcuse's argument for censorship any more, though few use the general idea of democracy and its functions to both support and knock down justifications for free speech.
My contention is only this: as far as I can tell, an uncharitable reading of a popular philosopher does not do enough work to designate him as a pseudo-intellectual (and we have some weak evidence to counter, anyway - his work has attracted serious scholarly attention both agreeing and disagreeing with him, and the only other explanation is that all those people are pseudo-intellectuals too, or too stupid to realise it, which is a very strong claim; further, he studied and wrote extensively on aesthetics and philosophy using a wide array of classical and modern theory; was Heidegger too stupid to see he was a pseudo-intellectual too?).
Further, that the importance of his essay on free speech is overstated as the driver behind the movement today and in the past to criticise free speech.
Second, in various places you suggest Taibbi's piece is unfair because it renders judgement on the basis of a single essay. But his piece isn't just about one essay. In fact, the very gloss on the article, which isn't behind a paywall and can be found on twitter, says "reviewing Repressive Tolerance and other works by Herbert Marcuse" (emphasis mine). Incidentally, if you want to read the (whole) piece, it's been pasted on reddit, so no need to pay. (I guess he wouldn't get your business anyways, so no harm done.)
Third, I'm not saying - or to put it more precisely, Taibbi isn't saying - that Marcuse is pseudo-intellectual because of a disagreement in political views, nor that Taibbi disagrees with his premises. Instead, it's because the passage I quoted (from Marcuse) is little more than a concept bouillabaisse, a rattling off of bad things, bearing absolutely no relationship to one another save that they all suck. Or can you explain what business "planned obsolescence" has in the same sentence as indoctrination and special forces? How is the former even remotely as important as the latter? Taibbi probably puts it more colourfully:
> People who do intellectual work should feel a responsibility to make sure the words they use at least roughly correspond to their ostensible meaning, but like a lot of German intellectuals, Marcuse had been mired in dialectical comparisons for so long that his sense of proportion was fucked beyond recognition. The man cited aggressive driving in arguing an emergency so dire that a suspension of all civil liberties was warranted.
Final remark: you say that this is worse than what the NYT did to Scott Alexander, but I think being called a pseudo-intellectual is not nearly as bad as being doxxed and smeared as a white supremacist. The target of the NYT piece, Scott Alexander, has already experienced real-world career consequences as a direct result of NYT's doxxing and publication. The same can't be said for Taibbi's piece.
You're in luck, because we're mostly talking about papers here, rather than books. What books there are usually are just compendia of papers, in the modern academic philosophy way of making books these days. Here's a comment I wrote a while ago with what I think are important papers in the area: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23136757
It's worth noting that there are responses and counter-responses etc. I'm at the point where the discussions don't matter so much; I'm not convinced that the state is legitimate anyway, and certainly not the modern bourgeois state... with its dangerous driving.
>Or can you explain what business "planned obsolescence" has in the same sentence as indoctrination and special forces?
Marcuse's aim in a sentence like that is to make the reader think about connections, to link these things as part of the social and economic machinery. It's not that they're related in themselves, they are related as products of capitalism as supported by the political state and the economic market. For example, the list makes me think of the extreme economy of time.
>Marcuse had been mired in dialectical comparisons for so long that his sense of proportion was fucked beyond recognition
I don't think it's fair to say that Marcuse had lost any sense of scale between wrongs; rather, I think that to list things big and small actually gives the reader a sense of scale of the system. With some books, I think, it's appropriate to immerse the reader and make them relate their own experience when reading. Too many do not make good enough use of rhetoric, and sometimes the rhetoric is used as a battering ram (as I think Taibbi's essay has).
I think there are two possible schools of thought here; that perhaps Marcuse's argument is entirely compromised by the presentation of concepts (and perhaps even his point is compromised), or the arguments or general point stand even when the rhetoric and 'feel' conveyed is peeled back. Now of course it may be the case that even if his point is not compromised, it is logically flawed. That's fine too, but it needs more than what I see as a namecally hit piece.
>its reporters are (very stridently, openly, and indeed, melodramatically) agitating internally and externally in a bid to silence certain nonconforming voices
I have sympathy for this view of what they're doing, but I think it would also pay to examine why Taibbi is writing the article he is writing too. Is it to shut down people who would bring out Marcuse in an argument? Is it to convince philosophers that Marcuse isn't all he's made out to be? I really can't tell, but the way it's written is making me think there's more to it than a simple essay on Marcuse. It doesn't serve as an argument against his point or really any of his positions.
Look at the way philosophers and economists have treated Marx. While there are plenty of angry people on the internet writing against him, generally, the response is measured. Scott's article on Marx is at least somewhat charitable. Even the great Paul Samuelson took his arguments to task. But the focus generally wasn't on Marx's use of rhetoric. I don't think it's a far stretch to say Taibbi has effectively written an article to cancel Marcuse long after he's dead and his influence waned, where the only people making use of his work is a small subreddit and a small community of philosophers who specialise in the Frankfurt School.
It's specifically people in the U.S. who are often unfamiliar with this craziness, because they were introduced to it quite late. To many others in the Western world, these ideas are, yes, genuinely worrying for obvious reasons, but also quite laughably old-hat.
Make up your own words and world views then refuse to back them up with studies that can falsify them.
Instant success.